X-X-X-X-X-X Chapter Nine X-X-X-X-X-X Her living room clock ticked off long seconds as she waited for him to understand what she was telling him. Cold night air stirred her curtains, and the breeze made her shiver. The papers on her coffee table flared up, threatening to blow away, and she smacked a hand down on them. "This...this can't be right." Mulder clutched a page in each hand, looking back and forth between them. "You're the one who told me what they were," she said. "You're the one who stole them from Brandt's lab." She'd been shaking since she had first made the connection, but saying the words aloud calmed her. She was no longer alone with her knowledge. "Maybe these aren't the same papers." "You've had them all this time. They were just sitting there in the file cabinets." How many times had he asked her to read through the old cases? That first year, he must have egged her on at least a dozen times, telling her to immerse herself in X-files history. She hadn't bothered. She hadn't cared where the X-files had been; she'd only cared where they were going. "No, I never had these. Not since Diana left. She took this with her so I wouldn't get caught with the evidence of the break-in. She said she was protecting me. Scully..." He moved to get in her line of sight, but she turned away. "You have to believe me. I didn't know what this was." She gripped the back of the armchair and looked at the ceiling. "I always thought it was an accident, that no one could have seen Duane Barry coming. That's what I told myself. It's part of working this job, coming in contact with dangerous and mentally ill people. I knew the risks. I...I made choices." She turned to him, and he stood there, the pages pinched in his hands, his expression troubled. "I chose to work with you." "Scully, I swear I didn't know." "No," she said hoarsely. "You didn't know." He held the printouts in front of him again. "I looked at these a thousand times. It never made any sense. I thought it was about his research, maybe test results, but I couldn't break the code. I went over them every way I could think of, but nothing ever clicked. If I had figured it out..." "Don't," she said, more sharply than she'd intended, and Mulder flinched. "I'll understand if you hold me responsible," he whispered. She shook her head, her eyes closed. She'd been holding him responsible for years, at least a little bit. His sister, his work, his unceasing search, but somehow she had paid the price. "I wanted it to be true," she said at last, "that we had that kind of power. If you could have stopped this, maybe there was a way to stop it from happening again." "There is," he said, a little desperate. "We finally have proof." He held up the pages, fisting them so tight they wrinkled in his grasp. "Proof of what, Mulder? Those pages were stolen seven years ago from a man who's now been dead for over a week. I can pick my name out from this list but untangling the rest of it may be damn near impossible, and if precedent holds, most of them are probably dead from cancer by now." "There is still one person left who can put it all together," he replied as he started for the door. "Mulder, wait a second. What are you going to do?" His mouth was set in a grim line. He was angrier than she'd ever seen him. "I'm going to find Diana," he said. "And then I'm going to find some answers." X-X-X-X Mulder baked like beans inside his tin can home. He opened the only window on the trailer that he could, as the others were stuck shut. The remnants of the hurricane had disappeared, leaving strong, clear sunshine and tree branches scattered outside on the ground. He wore his T- shirt from the night before, scratchy cotton stiff from the dried rainwater. He lay in the narrow bunk and tossed his orange repeatedly at the low ceiling. The pillow still smelled like Scully's hair. He had kissed her part that morning before she'd left, her head in his hands. "Don't do anything rash," he'd murmured at her temple. She'd held his hands and nodded, but she hadn't looked him in the eyes. Partly he remained trapped from his own handiwork. He'd made himself the target and in doing so had removed most of his powers of investigation. Partly he just didn't know where to turn next. Maybe he didn't even want to know. If it turned out Scully was guilty, she was liable to turn herself in or remove the chip. Either option could be a death sentence. When Diana's phone rang, he stopped juggling the orange and checked the caller ID, but the number was not one he recognized. Scully, he thought, from a pay phone. But he said nothing when he clicked it on, waiting for the other party to speak first. "Mulder," said Skinner in a low voice. "We need to talk." "This line is secure?" "Of course, what kind of idiot do you take me for? But I don't know how much longer we can keep this little charade going. Rivera's dogs are circling. He's got a cleaning woman holed up downtown, and the word is that she heard you and Diana arguing the night of the murder." "That's good." Mulder ran a hand through his hair and walked the worn carpet from end-to-end. "As long as he's still focused on me, we're doing okay." He hesitated. "Scully told me you took her gun." "You've talked to her? Jesus, Mulder, you like living dangerously." "She wouldn't hurt me." "I don't mean that. I mean her phones are probably bugged and Rivera no doubt put a tail on her." "We were careful." "Did you tell her?" Skinner asked, and Mulder didn't answer, so Skinner's voice got even quieter. "Did you tell her about the gun?" "I told her." He stopped pacing and rested against the short kitchen counter. "She says she wasn't there that night." "That's all well and good except she's been places before without any memory of it." "I know that," Mulder snapped. No one needed to explain the situation to him. He'd been going over every interaction he'd had with her over the past few weeks, wondering if there were clues he could have missed. Scully at the shooting range. Scully exhausted and distracted at her desk. Scully in his bed. She hadn't talked about it and he hadn't asked. Now he was afraid of the answer. "I'm going to figure out something," he told Skinner. "I just need more time." "We have another problem." "What's that?" "River a is trying to get a warrant for the Bureau. He wants the gun." "Can he do that?" "I don't know. I don't think so, but it's possible he can find a way in on a limited warrant. I don't want him setting foot in here at all if we can help it, but my opinion isn't going to carry much merit on this subject." "We've got to get rid of it." "I was thinking about that," Skinner said, and the odd tone in his voice made Mulder's heart skip a beat. "What are you talking about?" "If it's like you say, if it's a frame job...without the gun, there's no frame. I don't think Rivera could build a case against you or anyone else if he's missing the murder weapon." He squeezed his eyes shut. It's not like he hadn't had this idea himself, even as he was running out the front door with Diana's body cooling behind him. Just dump the gun in the river or bury it in the woods and chances were that no one would ever recover it. But then he would never know the truth. "We can't," he said at last, hating the words even as he said them. "Mulder..." "Not after we've told her. Can you imagine living with this forever? Whatever the answer turns out to be, Scully deserves *some* sort of answer. And to get it, we're going to need that gun. We can't risk Rivera getting hold of it." "You realize that if we get that answer for Scully, we may not be able to protect her." Mulder's bleak silence was his answer. Skinner sighed. "What do we do with the gun in the meantime?" "I'll take it back," Mulder replied immediately. "Do you think that's wise?" "I can't get in any deeper than I already am. You should try to stay out of it from here on." Skinner snorted. "Fat chance. I'll bring the gun myself. Where do you want to meet?" "There's this jungle gym..." X-X-X-X-X It was after hours but Diana was still at work, lights burning in the basement even as the rest of the Bureau sat cloaked in shadow. She didn't hear him approach so he was able to lean in the doorway watching her for a long minute. So many times he'd observed her this way, her dark head bent over her reading, the glow of the computer screen reflected on her glasses. A million years ago, he might have crept up behind her, pushed aside her thick hair and kissed the warm spot at the base of her neck -- just about the spot where Scully's chip now lay. Eventually the anger radiating from his being must have registered because she looked up with an expectant gaze. "Oh, it's you," she said coolly, and removed her glasses. She rubbed the bridge of her nose in a tired gesture. "It's really too late to argue, if that's why you've come." "I asked Scully." He was surprised at how calm he sounded, like the words came from another person instead of somewhere inside him. She didn't pretend to misunderstand. "I thought you might. What did she say?" "What would you expect her to say?" he asked as he moved into the room. "She was marked as a lab rat almost a decade ago, and you made sure her torture went ahead on schedule." "Let's not get overly dramatic here, Fox. I had no idea what that list meant back then, and I most assuredly didn't know her name was on it." "Excuse me if I don't quite believe you." "Believe what you like," she said as she pushed back her chair and stood up. "I couldn't have stopped it any more than you could." "You didn't want to stop it." She tried to pass and he grabbed her arm, his fingers biting into her flesh. "You wanted to stop me. That's why you took the papers. If I had figured it out, Brandt might have been shut down." "Let go of me." "She could have died." He yanked her arm harder, and she resisted, her whole body tense. "They used her up and just threw her away like garbage. She came back so weak they even took her off life support." She tried to jerk free again. "I'm sorry for what happened to Scully. I am. But this is your problem, Fox. This is exactly why they can continue to manipulate you and why you're never going to be able to find the real truth in all this. Here's some truth for you: it's not about Scully. It's not about you, or about Samantha. You have these grand aspirations about saving the world, but your world is always so small." "You're calling me myopic and saying that it somehow justifies your deceit. If I was blind then I must have deserved it, is that it?" He shoved her backwards. "You can call my moral compass narrow, but at least I have one." "The future's on the line, Fox. Your way may get us there but then again it might not. Sometimes a person has to hedge her bets." "So that's what you were doing with Brandt -- hedging your bets in his bed." "I was gaining information." "For whom?" he asked, stepping closer to her again. "Who is the ultimate beneficiary of your services?" "I am," she replied with grim determination, and he gave a bitter laugh. "So we're not so different then. Your world is smaller than mine." "I gave you access to those documents, didn't I? You never would've even had the chance to get inside the Brandt lab if it wasn't for me. You'd still be here in perfect, blissful ignorance!" "I'm supposed to thank you for setting me up." "I told you, it wasn't a setup. I had no idea those guards were coming. I got us in and I got us both out again, and then I took the heat for it too. A little thanks would not be out of the question here." He took another step toward her, and she backed up. "Who ordered Scully's abduction?" he asked evenly. "I--I don't know. I don't know how they chose the names." "You know." He had her nearly trapped against the wall. "I tried to find out, I did. I never got that far inside. I don't know who makes those decisions, but it wasn't Brandt." "The Smoker?" She licked her lips. "Maybe. I don't know." "But you know him. You know his friends in low places." "I can give you a phone number if you want. That's all I have." "I don't want numbers. I want names. I want places. I want to know everything you know or ever have known about the men behind these abductions." For the first time, her expression turned to pain, and she dropped her chin to her chest, shaking her head. "No," she said softly, "You don't." He pinned her with his knees, staring intently at her face as she held herself as far away from him as she could. Up this close, he could see she'd aged, could smell the make- up she'd used to hide this fact. Foundation caked the wrinkles at her eyes and mouth. Her cheeks sagged just a bit. "Still like it rough, Fox?" she asked, but he could detect the underlying tremor in her voice. He reached up with one hand and ran his fingers down the length of her hair, not quite touching. "I could kill you right here." She swallowed. "Go ahead. I'm half dead anyway." She made herself look at him and would not turn away under the force of his gaze. "Take a good long look. This is what happens to people who know too much. I don't know how Scully got on the list, but I know I got added quite purposefully." "Then tell me." "I can't," she whispered, and he shoved himself roughly at her, making her wince. "Tell me!" Tears leaked from the corners of her eyes but she didn't wipe them away. "For once, I'm doing things your way. I'm choosing the small victory, Fox. If I could help you, believe me, I would." He wanted to shake her, rattle her until her eyes rolled and everything she'd hidden from him came tumbling out between them. When he spoke, his voice was strangled, anger literally choking him. "I gave you everything...every opening, every chance. And you gave me nothing." He released her abruptly, breathing hard, and they looked at each other. "You make me sick," he said as she righted herself. "Yes, well, at least you still have that luxury." She snapped her suit jacket down over her hips and started gathering papers from the desk. "You can take your secrets to the grave, but they won't die with you. I'll find out eventually." She halted awkwardly and looked almost beyond him, her gaze clouded. If she was imaging the future or the past, he could not guess. "I'm counting on it," she said. He left her standing at his desk, surrounded by a life he'd built, the evidence of her betrayal folded against his heart. X-X-X-X Mulder added a sweatshirt and an old Yankees hat to his grunge look as he set out to meet Skinner. As before, he parked a respectable distance from the park and walked the two blocks to the side entrance. The sun shone high in the sky but the park was empty; all the kids were in school. Skinner stood by the jungle gym, his bald head gleaming and his dark coat flapping in the stiff breeze. He squinted in Mulder's direction and then looked away. Mulder scanned the outskirts of the park, searching the bushes and trees for signs of anyone suspicious. He loped up the grassy knoll to the playground, and Skinner straightened his stance. "You look like hell," he said by way of greeting. "Hell's my address these days." He gestured with his chin. "Did you bring it?" Skinner withdrew a paper sack from the inside of his coat. "I don't see how this helps you." "It helps me by keeping it out of Rivera's hands for a little while longer." Mulder felt the heavy outline of the gun through the thin paper, and he tucked it carefully under his sweatshirt. "What are we going to do about Scully?" Mulder kicked the dirt and looked around again. "You took her gun, right? At least we know she's not going to shoot anyone." Skinner scowled and shoved his hands in his pockets. "You told her about the gun. There's no way I'll be able to keep her away from this investigation now." "I wouldn't bet on that." He waited a beat. "Those answers Scully desperately needs...experience says she won't be able to bring herself to ask for them." "I'm going to hold you to that." Mulder nodded. "I'll be in touch." He pushed away from the bars and watched from the corner of his eye as Skinner grew smaller and smaller in his wake. But then there were two Skinners, then four, and they were closing in fast. Mulder whirled and found a SWAT team bearing down on him, guns at the ready. Men surrounded him on all sides, but it was a smaller, thinner guy who emerged from the fray. "Hold it right there, Agent Mulder!" The business end of a revolver pointed at Mulder's chest. "Don't you move a muscle." Mulder raised his hands in the air. "You must be Rivera." "Down on the ground, face first, and keep your hands where I can see them. I don't want any funny business." Mulder lowered himself to the grass, the smell of dirt filling his senses. The gun dug into his belly as five pairs of dark boots gathered around him. "Put your hands behind your back," Rivera ordered. A moment later, the cuffs snapped around Mulder's wrists, biting painfully into his skin. Rivera grabbed him by the arm and jerked him to his feet. Mulder stumbled for balance and looked his captor in the eyes. Rivera assessed him with a level gaze. "You're not the toughest mouse I ever trapped." He jerked a nod at one of his colleagues. "Frisk him." Mulder closed his eyes, resigned as a muscled guy with bulging forearms started patting him down. It took him less than two seconds to come up with the gun. "Lookie here," the burly guy said with a leer. Rivera took the sack and peered inside. "I've been looking for this," he said as he glanced at Mulder. "Even more than I've been looking for you. And here I find the two of you together. What are the odds?" Another SWAT team member appeared behind him, pushing Skinner roughly. The AD also wore cuffs. "Great, now the gang's all here," Rivera said. "We'll go get this gun logged in and then you and I are going to have a long talk, Mr. Mulder." "I don't have anything to say to you." Rivera shrugged. "Maybe you talk to me, and I don't charge your boss here with aiding and abetting a felon." "You can't do that." "Oh?" "I'm not a felon." Rivera didn't smile. "Suit yourself, federal agent man. Now you're going to come play in my house, with the local boys. I've got a four-by-seven cell with your name on it." X-X-X-X-X Mulder rubbed his hands over both cheeks, his new beard scratching at his palms. He'd been sitting alone in the interrogation room for going on three hours, with nothing but gray walls and the sight of his own reflection for company. A uniformed officer had dropped off a Coke ages ago, and Mulder soothed himself by playing table hockey with the empty can. At last, the door opened and Rivera came in holding a brown file folder; his expression was unreadable. "I want my phone call," Mulder said. "Tough. You turn yourself in, you get a phone call. You bust my balls for four days, you get nothing." He drew the chair across the cement floor and took a seat across from Mulder. "Then I have only one word for you: lawyer." "Oh, that's too bad," Rivera said, feigning disappointment. "Now we don't get to talk. I can't tell you what we found on the gun." He made a show of opening the folder, licking his thumb, and leafing through the pages. Mulder tried to get a look but Rivera didn't let him get close enough. He held the folder back and really studied it. "Yes, sir-ee, very interesting. I never saw this coming." Mulder's pulse quickened and sweat beads broke out on the back of his neck. Had Scully already been arrested? He shifted in his chair and the scraping sound echoed in the bare room. "You say you're not a felon," Rivera said, "but I'm having trouble figuring out how that squares with everything I know to be true. I know you were there the night Diana Fowley was killed. I know you fled the scene, and I know you hid out instead of coming forward when you had to know we were looking for you. Best of all, I find you with her gun right on your person -- a gun you stole from her house the night of the murder. You look like a guilty man, Agent Mulder. A very guilty man." "Looks can be deceiving." "Oh, this I know. Take me, for example." He closed the folder and rested it in front of him. "People see my dark skin, they hear my Spanish accent. Everyone thinks I am Mexican. They don't realize I am from Colombia." He tapped the side of his head. "False assumptions. We all make them. So this is why I'm in here with you now, to give you a chance to explain yourself, to see if you can tell me why I shouldn't book you on murder charges this very afternoon." "Because I didn't do it?" Mulder ventured. He folded his arms over his head. "I don't know if your dogged investigation turned up this key fact, but Agent Fowley was shot last year and nearly killed." "I did learn this. She was working with you at the time." "You don't think I'm responsible for that shooting too?" "They never caught the guy," Rivera mused. "Funny about that." "Maybe whoever it was tried again." "Maybe." Rivera lifted the edge of the folder and peered at the contents again. Mulder twitched and placed his hands on the table to still them. Even with the prints on the gun, it wouldn't be enough to arrest her, he reasoned. Not until they proved it was the murder weapon. "Making you nervous?" Rivera asked. "Are you trying to?" Rivera flashed a white-toothed smile, but it disappeared quickly. He leaned across the table. "I would be," he whispered. "If I was you." He picked up the folder again and sat back in his chair. "What if I was to tell you that your prints turned up on the gun?" His heart stopped but he tried not to blink. "It was in my possession. That doesn't make me a killer." "It does if you had your finger on the trigger." Rivera watched him closely for a reaction, so Mulder didn't give him any. "I wouldn't know anything about that." "No? You think we didn't find your prints on the trigger?" "If you did, it's not because I put them there." "You'd be right," Rivera said, his expression grim. "We didn't find them. In fact, we didn't find any prints at all." Mulder was glad he was sitting because otherwise his knees would have given out. His mouth went suddenly dry. Skinner, he thought. Shit. Thank God. "But here's the part I find really interesting," Rivera continued, taking out a page from the folder. "No prints, I can understand that. You're a long-time fibbie and I'm sure you know how to make evidence disappear. Hell, I would've wiped my prints off too. I wasn't really expecting to find anything, but we've got to look. Not a single print anywhere on that gun. What my lab guys did find? Print dust." He slid the paper across to Mulder. "See there? Traces of it all over the gun. And so that gets me thinking. A guilty man flees the murder and takes the incriminating weapon with him. But why on earth would he print the gun if he was the shooter? The only answer I've got is that maybe he wasn't so guilty after all. Maybe he only wanted us to think he's guilty because he's covering for someone else." Mulder slid the paper back to the detective. "I think I'd really like that lawyer now." X-X-X-X-X Scully parked in the visitor's lot of the precinct and walked past a half dozen cruisers on her way to the front door. She kept her head down and tried not to look directly at them. Part of her still worried this was a trap, but Mulder had called and said he'd been arrested. She had little choice but to come. The desk sergeant summoned Rivera for her, and he appeared looking less smug than she would have imagined. "Agent Scully, I didn't realize you held both a medical and legal degree. Talk about an over-achiever." "What are you talking about?" "Mulder said he was calling a lawyer." He bit into a shiny apple and started crunching. "I assumed that must be you." "Can I see him?" "I'll even lead the way." He led her to the back where the interrogation rooms were but stopped just outside the door. The narrow hallway filled with the scent of apple. "Talk fast. We're going to take him to booking in a few minutes." "Booking him for what?" Her heart had lodged in her throat, pounding out a steady beat just behind her epiglottis. She kept her hands in her pockets so he couldn't see them shaking. "Hindering a police investigation for starters. The list grows from there." He turned the handle with a sharp twist and let the door fall open. "He's all yours." "Mulder?" He stood as she entered, relief plain on his hairy face. "Hey," he said. "Turns out he was following Skinner instead of you. We both got picked up in the park." "Skinner's here?" She slid into the seat across from him, and he sat back down. "They hauled him in for helping me. I haven't seen him since." He reached out and took her hand, and she curled her fingers around his. "How are you holding up?" She felt sick. "They're going ahead with the booking. They'll prosecute you." "Good luck to them." He glanced over her shoulder to the two-way mirror behind her. "They barely have enough evidence to hold me. There were no prints on the gun." "What?" She jerked her hand free in surprise. "Shh. Rivera showed me the report. They found fingerprint powder but no prints." He'd wiped them off, covering for her. "Oh, God, Mulder..." "Shh, shh," he said again, trying to get her hand free from where she'd clenched it against her body. "It'll be okay." "How did he get the gun?" He looked sheepish. "I kind of had it on me when I was arrested." "Then they will charge you. The won't need your prints if they found you with the murder weapon." She pulled free and gripped her head with both hands. "You wanted to make yourself look guilty, Mulder, and you did a damn fine job of it. They have a witness at the scene, another who overheard your argument with Diana, and now the murder weapon. They won't need fingerprints to convict you." "Let me worry about that." "And how am I supposed to do that? How can I sit here and just let you take the fall for this?" "I'm not taking the fall." He gave an anxious look at the mirror again. "We can talk more when we have less of an audience. I need you to sit tight for now, okay, Scully? I'll figure something out." Already her head was swimming. She swore she could actually feel her brain bobbing inside her skull. "No," she said, her voice breathy but certain. "I have to find out what happened. I have to." He shook his head violently and squeezed her hand so hard it hurt. "Scully, listen to me. You can't fix this on your own. You have to give me time to think. I'll get out of here on bail, right? We can figure out what to do then." "Mulder, if you're right about what really happened..." "We don't know what happened. We don't know that." "But if, if it's true." She tried to swallow but her throat had gone dry. "I can find out." He looked alarmed. "What are you proposing?" She leaned way across the table, and he met her halfway. Her heart was beating so fast she was surprised it didn't knock on the wood. "No matter who pulled the trigger," she whispered near Mulder's ear. "I didn't want her dead. But I think I know who did." "Scully, no," he whispered back. He pulled away and looked at her. "It's too dangerous. You'll never be able to prove anything." Either the Smoker had made her a murderer, or he'd done the setup himself. She was sure of this. And thanks to Diana, she now had his phone number. "It's the only way." "No," he said, suddenly loud. She jumped and he lowered his voice again. "These men leave no loose ends," he murmured, reaching for her once more. This time he touched her cheek. She leaned into his hand for just a moment. "I'll let you know what I find out," she said as she got up to leave. "Don't do it. Scully, please." Tears stung her eyes. He'd never begged her for anything. "I have to know," she said, her voice thick. "One way or the other." "At least wait for me to post bail." "I've got to go," she said, heading for the door. "Scully, wait. Wait for me!" She practically fled -- past the Coke machine, past Rivera with his apple core and surprised expression, out of the station and into the cold sunshine. Only when she'd reached the car did she let the tears come. Mulder was right that she could be walking willingly towards her death, but at least she would have the truth. One way or another, she would be free. X-X-X-X-X End chapter nine. Continued in chapter ten. Many thanks to Amanda for proofing! Coming into the home stretch... Laptop works great! Eyes? Not so much. It's been a bad week for the peepers, so if I owe you email, it's coming soon, promise. Feedback? I'll soak it in green tea and cover my eyes with it. ;-) syn_tax6@yahoo.com