X-X-X-X-X-X-X Chapter One X-X-X-X-X-X-X The basement office had been solitary but notorious, so to Scully the tic-tac-toe bullpen cubicles on the third floor actually felt more anonymous. But even six years in, Mulder still had a way of shattering her illusions. He sauntered over, licking a bit of jelly donut from the end of his thumb as he paused to lounge by her thin gray wall. "These aren't half bad today," he told her. "You should get one before Agent Tankersley gets back from the DMV." Scully rested her forehead on the heel of her hand. "The man's name is Ankersley, Mulder." "Oh, is it?" He licked his thumb again. "I must've heard wrong." "You can ascertain that he's at the Registry of Motor Vehicles this morning, but you can't get his name right." "The registration sticker on his Beemer expired two days ago." He shoved another bite of donut into his mouth. "Ordinarily he might not be in such a hurry to get it taken care of, but Dick Roberts was saying in the men's room yesterday that he was thinking of turning him in." "I've always wondered what sorts of things men talk about in there," she said. "Now the mystery is gone." "Don't you want to know *why* Dick Roberts was thinking of turning him in?" "Not especially." "Paper clips." "Excuse me?" "Tankersley took two boxes of paperclips from the closet last week instead of one, so there weren't any left when Roberts went looking for them." "If Roberts knows who has the paperclips, why can't he just ask Tank--Ankersley for the other box?" "He did, and Tankersley lied about having them. Hence the plot to turn him in." Scully shook her head and focused on her computer screen in the hopes of getting Mulder to return to his seat. He didn't take the hint though, instead polishing off his donut and draping an arm over the top of her cubicle. "But I'd much rather be slacking off with Bill Keene," he said. "He's off trying to get his wife pregnant. For the third day in a row, I might add." She squeezed her eyes shut. "I don't want to know how you know this." Mulder tapped the knot of his necktie. "He went home for 'lunch' the other day and came back wearing a different tie. Yesterday it was a different shirt. I'd think maybe he was getting a little action on the side, but he's got about sixteen pictures of his wife tacked up over there. Seriously, the man should just have her face put on some wallpaper and be done with it." It was times like this that she wondered just what he deduced from watching her. For example, her doctor's appointment the following week -- she had the number circled discreetly on the calendar with no notation as to the significance, but she now held out little hope that Mulder was unaware. "Mulder, don't you have some actual work to do?" "No," he said flatly, and she looked up at him. "I've called six farmers today and inquired about the size of their manure piles. Six loads of crap is my limit before lunchtime. And, I might add, in no universe with a sense of justice could any of this be construed as actual work." "Then maybe you'd like to go sweep the restrooms for gossip and allow me to do my work in peace." "Sure, okay, Scully. I know you can't beat the timed level on Mine Sweeper without a lot of practice." "Out. Now." He whistled as he turned to take his seat, and Scully quickly brought Mine Sweeper up from the task bar to quit the program. "Hey," he said, sticking his head over the wall between them. "I wasn't playing!" "No, look at this," he said as he held out a plain white envelope marked "Mulder" on the front. "Did you see who left this?" "No, what is it?" "I don't know," he said as he slit it open. "But it wasn't here when I got up ten minutes ago." Ten minutes ago, she had been in the ladies' room, where she was the sole occupant and no one had any juicy office tidbits to share. Mulder took out what looked to be a short newspaper article. "What is it?" she asked again as she stood up to go peer over his shoulder. The headline read, "Famed AIDS researcher dies in car crash." Pictured was a white-haired man in a lab coat, and the caption identified him as Christopher L. Brandt. "I've heard of him," Scully said. "He was one of the youngest researchers ever to be awarded a genius grant, and there's talk that he's on the short list every year for the Nobel Prize in Medicine for his work developing antiretroviral medications. It's a shame he's dead." "Yeah," Mulder said, not really paying attention to her as he read the article. "It says the crash is believed to be accidental but authorities are investigating anyway. Not everyone was a fan of his research." "Why would someone leave this for you?" "I was one of the people who wasn't a fan." "What? Why? His work has saved thousands of lives." He didn't answer. "Mulder?" She glanced up from the article to look at him, but he was looking elsewhere. She followed his gaze across the room and saw Diana Fowley standing there. In her hands was a plain white envelope. X-X-X-X It was raining the first night Mulder broke into the NIH research lab, a great booming thunderstorm that hid the sound of her voice through the earpiece. "Did you find them yet?" she asked as sheets of water coursed down the high windows. He couldn't answer because he had a flashlight in his mouth. They had used a stolen keycard to get into the rooms, but he still had to pick the lock on the file cabinets in Brandt's office. His teeth cut into the plastic ridges as he conjured up some color commentary. Excess rainwater trickled from behind his ears, where it followed the line of his neck down into his already damp collar. He wasn't even sure he was rattling the right drawer because the cabinets weren't marked from the outside. "We've got five more minutes before the guard returns," she hissed in his ear. The drawer came free at last and he started pawing through it as quickly as he could. The folders were marked with numbers, not names. He yanked out a handful and opened the top file, shaking his head back and forth to scan the page with the flashlight. The printouts meant nothing to him and he didn't see Amber Hathaway's name anywhere on the sheets. He flipped another folder to the top and repeated the process. A fat raindrop fell from his forehead down onto the paper, where it created an ink-stained smear. "We've to get out of here," she said from down the hall. He let the flashlight fall onto his stack of folders. "Not yet. I haven't found her." "There's no more time!" "Just one more," he said, reaching for the next drawer. "Mulder, you can't--" He never found out what it was he couldn't do because she crackled and faded out. Seconds later, an alarm sounded in the building. He shoved the drawer shut, grabbed the files and ran back towards the main door of the lab. Overhead, the fire alarm flashed and blasted its warning. He heard voices in the hall. "Diana?" He fumbled with the earpiece, shouting over the terrible noise. "Are you there?" She didn't answer and the piece fell down around his neck again as he rounded the corner into the actual lab. His wet sneakers skidded on the floor and he crashed into the door at top speed. Diana was gone and he didn't see anyone in the hall. "Come on, come on," he said to himself as he turned the keycard over to get the strip aligned. His fingers shook and the flimsy plastic snapped through the reader, but the tiny light did not turn green. Mulder glanced down the hall and tried again. The light remained red and the door wouldn't open. He threw his shoulder against it, jiggling the knob, but the lock held steady. A shadow appeared down the hall as someone prepared to come around the corner. Mulder ducked down and then risked a quick look: two guards, both with walkie-talkies, were heading his way. He pressed his back to the door and fumbled with the short-wave again. "Diana, where are you? Diana?" He got no answer and saw no sign of her in the hall. The guards had disappeared but the room started to fill up with flashing red lights from outside. The fire department had arrived. Mulder gave the keycard a few more desperate passes through the security lock. The alarm cut out, leaving only the sound of the rushing rain and the men's voices approaching in the hall. He backed away from the door slowly and then ran back across the lab. He leapt the high workbench easily but narrowly missed knocking over a shelf of glassware. The small, translucent windows had no handle and no visible method of opening. He pushed at them one after the other down the line, but they refused to budge. "Clear!" someone yelled from outside and down the hall. "I'll get the next one!" Mulder jumped down from the bench and threaded his way through the crowded lab until he reached a closet door at the back. He wedged himself in with the industrial-strength cleansers and the mop and bucket. After shoving the stolen folders down the front of his jacket, he took out his flashlight and scoped the tiny room. His heart skipped a beat at the sight of an air-conditioning vent. Outside, the heavy footsteps of the firemen grew closer. "I've got nothing. Check the closet." Mulder squirmed deeper back among the cleaning supplies, tucked the flashlight back in his pants, and tried his footing on a twenty-gallon container of glass cleaner. His fingers felt numb and useless as he used his lock pick to work the tiny screws. The grate loosened and he discarded it on the ground. With a deep breath, he hoisted his way into the narrow tunnel, squinting against the surge of dust that assaulted his eyes. He shimmied in like a snake, his feet just clearing the opening at the moment the closet door opened. Mulder did not so much as breathe as the seconds ticked off, just like counting between the lightning and thunder. One- one-thousand, two-one-thousand. "Nothing here," came the voice from outside. Mulder exhaled just as the next clap of thunder hit. He allowed himself a short rest, his hot face pressed on the dirty, cold metal. Then he began wiggling forward with the files pressed against his belly. He could feel them wrinkling at the edges but there was nothing he could do about it. He followed the vent for almost one hundred feet, far enough to bypass the entire Brandt laboratory. He emerged in an administrative office closer to the front parking lot. The door here had no doubt been locked earlier too, but it stood ajar after the firemen had come through the building. Mulder peered out into the semi-lit hallway before breaking for the emergency staircase. Voices echoed in the stairwell above him, so he hugged the wall and headed for the basement. The sign on the door said that an alarm would sound if it opened, but he had no other choice. He pushed the door out and a loud, angry alarm began to reverberate off the concrete walls. "What the hell?" someone hollered from several floors above him, but Mulder was already free. Rain beat down on him as he ran, plastering his hair flat against his skin. Sweet, salty water dripped into his open, panting mouth. He hit the thin tree line at the edge of the lot and ducked behind a large pine. "It's me," he said into the radio. "Where are you?" The bark scraped his back as he looked over at the research building. Maybe she had gotten caught inside. "Diana," he said again. "Do you read me?" The line crackled and he got no intelligible response. He was wondering if he could make it to the highway and hitch back when he saw a flash of headlights on the other end of the trees. Keeping a low profile, he worked his way along the edge until he reached the car. A flood of relief went through him as he realized it was her. She was wet too, he realized as he got inside. The humid interior smelled of wet hair and denim. "What the hell happened?" she asked him as she started the engine. He leaned his head against the leather and closed his eyes. His heart still pounded out a disco beat and his hands had not stopped trembling. "You were in the one in the hall," he said. "You tell me." "The fire alarm went off. I assumed you tripped it." Maybe he had somehow. His head hurt and it was hard to think. She glanced over at him, looking at his empty lap. "You didn't find it." "I just had time to grab these," he replied as he withdrew the crumpled folders. She stretched over just a bit, tilting her head to try to read the pages he'd lifted. "Those are from Brandt's office? What do they mean?" Mulder studied the printouts as best he could in the passing streetlamps. "Beats the hell out of me." "So help me, Fox, if we broke into the NIH to get his dry cleaning bill..." He grinned and nudged her with his elbow. "You loved every second. You'll be an addict now, breaking into government buildings all over the country. Today the NIH, tomorrow the Pentagon." "Speak for yourself. There was a time I thought I would work for the NIH and now here I am conspiring against it. I hope whatever you find in those files is worth what we risked to get them." Mulder settled back into his seat, a smile on his face and the contraband in his lap. The adrenaline had dulled to a mild buzz, leaving him pleasantly tingly. It was true, he supposed, that he enjoyed the risk more than Diana. This was his baby, after all, the project he'd been trying to get off the ground for almost two years. So later, when one of them had to go, it was only logical that Diana was the one to leave. X-X-X-X-X-X A sharp noise woke Scully and she sat up with a jolt, totally disoriented. For a fraction of a second, she listened in the dark, trying to discern what had awakened her. Her pulse thrummed in her throat and she gripped the cushions with both hands. The banging happened again, and this time she identified the sound as coming from her front door. Sleep receded as she rose and turned on the nearest lamp on her way to answer the pounding. "Who is it?" she called. "D.C. Police, Agent Scully." She cracked the door and found a man with a thin mustache and two uniformed officers waiting in the hall. "Can I help you?" she asked without letting them past. "Detective Rivera," said the man in front as he held up his shield for inspection. "I need to ask you some questions." "Questions about what?" He looked up and down the hall. "Maybe it would be better if we talked inside." "I'm fine right here," she said, still standing behind the door. "What do you want to ask me questions about?" "It's about Agent Mulder." "What about him?" "Have you seen him tonight?" Scully resisted the urge to look at her clock because she didn't want to seem like she was at a loss for information. "Why are you asking me about Mulder?" "Ma'am, I'll consider answering one of your question when you answer one of mine. So let's try this again, hmm? Have you seen Agent Mulder tonight?" "I, uh, I last saw him at work," she said, hoping she sounded sincere. Her memory was a bit fuzzy on the details. Rivera made a show of checking his notebook. "At work," he said, "that would be the Hoover building downtown." "Yes. Has something happened to Mulder?" "Not to my knowledge," he said, and glanced up from his notes. "About what time would you say this was that you last talked to Agent Mulder?" "I couldn't say," she said. "I didn't check my watch." "How was his demeanor at the time?" She folded her arms. "I want to know why you're asking about Mulder." "Oh, well, I'm sure I couldn't discuss that out here in the hall." Scully narrowed her eyes at all three of them, but the officers' placid expressions gave nothing away. Without a word, she let the door fall open and stepped back so they could enter the apartment. As she turned to shut the door behind them, she saw the clock read quarter past three, and her stomach seized. City detectives did not get up in the middle of the night unless someone was dead, near-dead or an elected official caught in bed with a prostitute. "I want to know why you're asking about Mulder," she said as the two uniformed officers began studying her belongings. Rivera went over to the couch but didn't sit down. "We need to talk to him," he said, "and when we went to his place, he wasn't there. I thought maybe you'd know where he went." "I don't." "You sure about that?" Rivera asked, looking around. The other two officers paused to watch her answer. "I'm quite sure. I told you, I haven't seen Mulder since this evening." "Actually, you didn't tell me that," Rivera said casually. "You said you weren't sure about the time you saw him last. 'I couldn't say,' is what you told me. Isn't that right, boys?" The smaller officer, who looked like he stepped out of an extra role on 'The Sopranos,' smirked and picked up the paperweight from her desk. "I can't be sure of the exact time," Scully said, "but it was late afternoon to early evening." "You saw him at work today and not since. That's your story." "That's the truth." "No contact since this afternoon. No phone call?" "No," she said, putting her hands on her hips. "And you would have been here if he called? Didn't leave the house for anything?" "No, I haven't left." "No email from Mulder? Nothing like that?" Her eyes flicked to her computer, which was off. "No," she said. Rivera followed her gaze to the computer and tilted his head as though pondering whether to challenge her reply, but he merely turned around again. "Why do you need to talk to Mulder?" she asked. "We think he may have witnessed a crime." The smirking detective picked up a book from her shelves and started leafing through it. Scully watched him for a second before returning her attention to Rivera. "What crime?" she asked. "A homicide. A woman was shot to death tonight over in Foggy Bottom. I think you may have known her." He consulted his notes. "Diana Fowley?" "Diana Fowley was shot?" "Sometime this evening, yes she was, ma'am. Right in her own home, too, which is such a shame. The reason we want to talk to Agent Mulder is that a neighbor of hers said she saw Mulder leaving Fowley's townhouse right around midnight. Midnight happens to be included in the range the time the M.E. told us that the murder went down, so we're wondering if maybe Agent Mulder might have seen the guy who did it." Hot prickles broke out across the back of Scully's neck. All three officers were watching her reaction closely, so she gave them none. "How can the witness be sure it was Mulder?" "You know, I had the same question," Rivera said as he sank down onto her sofa. "But it seems like he'd been there before, according to this neighbor. She'd seen him more than once, but of course she didn't know his name. No, they'd never been introduced. But she did write down this license plate number tonight. See?" He held out the notebook for her, and Scully inched close enough to see the numbers written there. It was Mulder's plate. "You have any idea what your partner was doing over at Diana Fowley's place so late tonight, Agent Scully?" "No. I..." She shook her head quickly. "No." Her phone rang then and the whole room froze. Scully hesitated for a moment, torn between grabbing the receiver and letting the machine take the call. "Someone must think you're up," Rivera said, and she crossed the room to the phone. "Hello?" she said carefully, her back to the cops. "Agent Scully." Her shoulders sagged as she realized it was Skinner, not Mulder, on the line. "Sir?" "I'm sorry to bother you at such a late hour, but I need to find Agent Mulder right away. Do you have any idea where he is?" "No, I don't," she said, taking a peek back at the men crowding her living room. "But you're not the only one looking for him." "The cops find you?" "That's right," she replied as neutrally as she could. "They're here now asking about Mulder." "Dammit, they've been two steps ahead of me ever since the call came in. It's imperative we get to him first, you understand? If you have any way of getting in touch with Mulder, I suggest you use it." "I'll take that under advisement," she said before hanging up the phone. "Not Mulder, I take it," Rivera said as he rose from her couch. "Not Mulder." "Right. Of course." He started ambling toward the door, and his backups took the cue to follow. "I guess we'll just be going then, unless..." He turned back and looked at her hopefully. "Unless maybe you feel like giving us the nickel tour here, maybe letting us check out your closets." "I don't think so," Scully answered, yanking open the door so they could leave. "Thought not." He took out a business card and handed it to her. "If you do talk to Mulder, tell him we have some questions, okay? And the longer this drags on, the tougher the questions get." Scully took the card but didn't answer. Rivera let the uniformed cops go on ahead as he lingered in front of Scully. "You're sure you want to stick with your story, especially the part about how you haven't left the apartment all evening?" "Are you suggesting I'm lying?" He shrugged. "I'm not suggesting anything, ma'am, but I do find it sort of funny that we come knocking on your door past three in the morning, and you answer dressed in a business suit." Scully looked down at her clothes, startled to find he was right. "I fell asleep on the couch," she said. Rivera pointedly dropped his gaze to her feet. "In your shoes? You must be some sleeper." She curled her toes inside her pumps and tightened her hand on the doorknob. "Goodnight, detective." "Goodnight, ma'am." He tipped an imaginary cap. "I'm sure I'll be in touch." X-X-X-X-X X-X-X-X-X-X-X Chapter Two X-X-X-X-X-X-X In the car, Scully tried his cell phone to see if he might pick up at the sight of her name glowing on the caller ID, but it rang through to his voice mail. "Mulder, it's me. I have to think that youšre aware of everyone whošs looking for you right now, and that therešs a good reason you're avoiding them. If you tell me what it is, maybe I can help." She hesitated, wondering if she should say something about Dianašs death. "Call me," she said at last, and snapped the phone shut with one hand. She kept it in her palm as she drove, clutched against the leather steering wheel. Pale, watercolor streaks of daylight broke up the night as cars began pouring out onto the freeways. She had lived in the area long enough that she knew the traffic rhythm, had in fact internalized to the degree that she could change lanes to avoid snares without the benefit of conscious thought. The car hurtled her forward in space faster than seventy miles per hour, but Scully remained only in her head. She tried to imagine what had happened, picturing Diana in her expensively appointed apartment, probably with a drink in hand. Had he rung the doorbell? Maybe he even had a key. Diana would not have been surprised to see him either way. Perhaps there had been an argument. She could recall the naked fury on Mulder's face from earlier in the day; if he had shown that face to Diana, maybe she had been concerned enough to go for her gun. Yes, Scully could see this all vividly -- Mulder, disheveled and livid, Diana, cool, still believing she controlled him, that she controlled them all. Scully even knew the things he might have shouted at her because she had said many of them to herself. She could feel herself in Mulder's shoes, demanding retribution. How he ended up with the gun, she couldn't say, but she could feel the weight of it. Diana's gun was the same as hers, the same as Mulder's, a familiar curved piece of steel with an easy trigger. When the gun went off in her head, she jumped, knocking her cell phone to the floor of the car. She had driven for ten minutes without seeing anything. As she made the last turn into Diana's neighborhood, she checked the rearview mirror to see if she was being tailed. No one appeared to be behind her. She parked her car a short way down from the townhouse and walked the pavement, her heels overloud against the sleepy, quiet morning. At the front of Diana's place sat two large metal garbage cans, spread strangely apart. One was near the curb with its lid on, the other overturned nearer to the walkway, its contents strewn across the concrete. Not a recycler, Scully thought as she noted two empty bottles of vodka in the mix. She stepped over the trash and went up to the small front porch. A uniformed officer wearing sunglasses stood up from a deck chair to stop her. "Protected crime scene, ma'am," he said as she reached for the door. "You can't go in there." Scully tugged her ID out of her pocket. "We're all on the same side of the law here, Officer..." She leaned in for a look at his nametag. "Traylor. I know procedure. I won't touch anything." "Well, I appreciate that, Agent..." He leaned over as she had and looked at her ID. "Agent Scully. But I have specific orders not to let anyone in, and that includes members of the FBI. In fact, I do believe your name was mentioned in particular." "Me?" "Mmm-hmm," he said, folding his arms over his broad chest. "So unless you want to sit out here with me all day, I suggest you get going." "The victim was a federal agent. The FBI has a vested interest in this case." She tried to look casual as she glanced in the tall, skinny glass window next to the door. "A vested interest doesn't equal jurisdiction. I'm sorry, but I can't let you in." "I knew the victim. I might be able to help." "Yeah? You should phone Detective Rivera and let him know. I'm sure he would appreciate any insights you can give him on this case. We could call him now." He began getting out his cell phone, and Scully stopped him. "No, no. That's all right. I've already talked to Detective Rivera." "Oh, then," said Traylor, clearly not surprised. "I guess your work here is done." He took a pointed step between her and the front door. Scully did a half-pivot on her heel, considering her options. If she tried to go around back, he would just follow. She was half tempted to pull out her gun and force her way inside. The sound of a car engine drawing nearer made them both turn to look. A shiny black Buick glided to a halt right in front and Skinner emerged. "I had a feeling you'd be here," he said to Scully as he came up the walk. "This little porch is getting awful crowded," Traylor said, not amused. "I'm guessing you must be Assistant Director Skinner." "You're very observant," Skinner answered. "Now how about observing this." He handed over a few sheets of folded paper. Traylor unfolded them and pushed up his sunglasses. "This is a federal witness warrant." "That's right, and we're going to look for Mulder inside. Now." "I can assure you he's not in there." "We want to check for ourselves." Skinner started to push past him. "Wait, I should talk to Detective Rivera about this." "You can fill him in while we're inside." Skinner mysteriously produced a key, which he used to cut down the police tape and then open the front door. Scully followed him over the threshold, and they both stopped in the dim entryway. The central air conditioning hummed in the background, but otherwise, the house was silent. "It happened in here," Skinner said as he moved to the left toward the living room. Scully didn't need anyone to tell her because she could smell the blood. Head wounds bled a lot, and the puddle wouldn't even be dry yet. The living room was monochromatic, with deep gray walls and a long black couch. On the glass coffee table sat a half-empty martini glass. The bloodstain was at the far end of the room near the back window. Sunlight was just starting to creep in through the blinds, sending a zebra-like pattern over everything. "How do they know she was killed with her own gun?" Scully asked. "I presume they don't know for sure yet," replied Skinner as he looked around the room. "Her gun is missing, so the presumption is that it's the murder weapon. Ballistics will have to run the tests for comparison." Mulder had his own gun -- two, actually. If Diana's was truly the murder weapon, then that was a point in Mulder's favor. "Did any of the neighbors hear the shot?" "Not according to what I know. The lady who called it in heard a commotion outside -- I'm guessing from the overturned garbage can -- and that's when she went to her window and saw Mulder." "Mulder knocked over the can?" Skinner shrugged. "Something doesn't make sense here," Scully said. "Detective Rivera told me the woman had seen Mulder here on several occasions before." "So?" Skinner was checking the windows but they appeared locked. "So why would she call the cops? Because he knocked over some garbage? That's not exactly a nine-one-one type of emergency. If she didn't hear the shot, why call it in at all?" "I don't know. We should definitely talk to her." Scully crossed back over to the other side of the house, where the kitchen resided. It had been remodeled recently, with spotless black granite countertops and a new stainless steel refrigerator. The stove looked like it was straight from the showroom floor, never been used. There were two upturned glass tumblers in the dish rack and a small collection of silverware left out to dry. An empty ashtray sat in the sink, and the trash basket underneath had been cleaned out. The seal on the fridge made a whooshing sound as Scully cracked it open. She found soda water, orange juice, some old fruit and a collection of take out containers. Closing the fridge, she went to inspect the back door. It had been dusted for prints but she saw no signs of forced entry. Whoever killed Diana, she had either let the person inside, or the killer had a key. Scully found the stairs and went up to the second floor where the bedroom was. The door was half closed, so she pushed it open with the flat of her hand. In the middle of the room sat a king-sized, four-poster bed. Scully stared at it as she realized it had been stripped, the sheets no doubt sent to the lab for processing. Diana had the same thick, light-gray carpet upstairs, which absorbed all the sound of Scully's footfalls as she entered the room. The air held the strong scent of Diana's perfume, and Scully had the urge to look over her shoulder, as if Diana could be pulled back from death by smell alone. She wondered if Mulder had ever realized that it was the perfume that gave him away. *Where have you been, Mulder? I've been trying to reach you for hours.* *I was following Imogene Brandt. She went to the dentist's and returned a library book. At one point, I had to check my pulse to make sure I hadn't expired from sheer boredom* *You went alone?* *Of course alone.* Skinner appeared in the doorway and he, too, looked at the empty bed. He cleared his throat but seemed reluctant actually to enter the room. "I don't see any indication here of what happened to Mulder. We'd better get out before Rivera shows up." Scully replaced the perfume bottle she was holding back onto the dresser top. "I thought you have a warrant." "I do, but I don't want to be answering any more of his questions." He cocked his head and squinted at her. "And I sure don't want you answering them." "I don't know where he is." "Right, so you've said. But word on the street is that Mulder and Diana had one hell of a fight yesterday outside his apartment building, and I'm betting you know what it was about." Scully bowed her head but said nothing. "You're not helping him by keeping me in the dark," Skinner told her. "Rivera didn't mention anything about a fight," she replied. Skinner's gaze flicked over her. "No, he wouldn't. He's not going to ask you until he knows the answer first." They left out the front so Officer Traylor could see they weren't taking anything with them. "Let's see if that neighbor is home," Scully said as they walked down the front path. Skinner stopped to look in both directions. "You know which house it is?" "No," she admitted. "Guess we'll have to try both of them." A man answered at the house on the right, and he said he had no knowledge of any disturbance the night before. At the other house, they got no answer at all. "They may have taken her in for more questioning," Scully said. She took out her card and scribbled a quick note on the back before sticking through the mail slot in the door. Skinner walked her back to her car, which she thought was odd until they reached the driver's side door. She went to get in, but he put a hand on the open door, effectively trapping her in place. "You and Mulder have been in some trouble before, but this is exciting new territory the two of you have discovered. I can't protect him -- or you -- unless I know what's going on." "I'm not sure anyone can protect him. I think maybe he's being set up." "Set up by whom?" Scully looked at his face, wondering if she could trust him. "Diana Fowley may have had alliances outside of the FBI." His jaw tightened just a bit and she couldn't tell whether he'd heard this news before. "What kind of alliances?" She decided to push her luck. "I think you know exactly what kind." This wasn't a surprise, she could tell, but he kept his expression neutral. "These other alliances, you think they may have been what got her killed." "I think it's a distinct possibility." Skinner looked away. "Well, there's another possibility." Scully waited, and he took a long time to look back at her. "If these alliances are the kind I think you're talking about, then their discovery could be the kind of motive the police are seeking." X-X-X-X-X Scully was so lost in thought that she didn't hear Mulder approach until he was almost on top of her. "Earth to Scully," he said as he slid his butt onto the plastic-coated MDF board that passed as her desk. She checked her watch. "You've been gone all day, Mulder. You're lucky Kersh didn't come looking for you." "As long as he thinks I'm tucked in here safely with the rest of his lackeys, everything's fine." "Is that what I am -- a lackey?" A smile played at his lips. "The boys upstairs made that mistake about you once, Scully. I don't think they'd be dumb enough to do it again." "They certainly would never again select me to keep tabs on you. Every time I turn around, you're gone again. One day it's a jaunt to the Bermuda Triangle, the next it's some newspaper clipping and you and Fowley disappear together for the better part of an afternoon." She looked around the bullpen. "Where is she, anyway?" "I couldn't say. I left her about an hour ago." "Courting you back to the basement, is she?" Mulder scoffed and picked up a paperclip chain from her desk. "Hardly. It's not like she could pull us back down there even if she wanted to -- the decision is over her head. No, this afternoon's exercise was about old business, not new." "Oh?" "Call it an X-file that predates the X-files." "Is this the part where you break out the slide projector?" she asked as she leaned back in her seat. "No, but I will take you to dinner." "Dinner," she said, her eyebrows raised. "And you're buying? This must be good." "Who said anything about buying?" he replied as he hopped off her desk. "I just said I'd take you." At the local bar and grill, Mulder had his jacket off, his tie loose around his neck, and one eye on ESPN. Scully sat in the booth across from him and picked at the corner of her beer label. He lounged on one end of the bench seat and palmed a fistful of nuts from the dish. "I was trying to get the X-files off the ground," he said, finally turning his attention to her. "Collecting old cases from Dales's files and adding any new clippings or tips that seemed to fit in with the overall theme of the unexplained. Diana was helping me. "One day I get this tip. A stripper named Lila Krunk is trying to get into an AIDS study that involves being abducted by aliens. An AIDS study, I should add, that is run by the US government. "So I tracked Lila down to get her story. Yes, she had HIV. She'd found out about two years before when she got pneumonia and it wouldn't go away. She'd survived the pneumonia but AIDS was still out there on the horizon. Then she heard about this other girl named Amber Hathaway who worked at club down the block. Amber, it seems, also had HIV, but she enrolled in a clinical trial sponsored by the NIH. According to Lila, the story was that Amber got abducted by aliens who cured the HIV and she was returned healthy. Lila wanted into this study too, and she called the NIH several times to inquire about the scientist who was supposedly conducting the clinical trial." "Let me guess," Scully said. "It was Christopher Brandt." Mulder pointed at her. "Give the little lady her prize." "I can imagine the NIH office was thrilled to hear from Lila." "Oh, naturally. They told her no such research was going on, that all of Brandt's trials were currently full, but most emphatically none of them involved aliens." "The story is a little wild, even for you." "Yeah, I was skeptical at first, I have to admit. So was Diana. She said that Lila Krunk had become code for 'total nutcase' at the NIH, and that if we looked like we bought into her story, we'd be nutcases too." "But you investigated anyway." Mulder sucked down a sip of beer from his bottle. "At that point, I was taking all comers. And a story that outrageous... well, it would make for good entertainment value even if Lila's claims were groundless." "So the first thing you did was talk to Amber, I presume." "Yes, and she backed up Lila's story. She said she'd been missing only two days in 'earth time' but in space it was over a year. The aliens gave her transfusion therapy and when she was returned, her HIV was gone. She even volunteered to take a blood test for us. Sure enough, it was clean." For the first time, Scully sat forward with interest. "Studies have shown it's possible for the viral load to diminish to a point that it's undetectable with current technology. It can also invade other cells and hide." "Yes, that's what Brandt said when we got a chance to talk to him. He said he was very pleased with Amber Hathway's remission, but there was no reason to think she was in fact cured." "And the part about the aliens?" Mulder smiled around his beer. "He pretty flatly dismissed that part too. 'Preposterous' and 'ludicrous' were the words he used, I believe." "I can't say I blame him. It's an outlandish claim." "Yes, I sort of thought so too, even when Amber's blood tested negative -- twice, I should add -- but I was able to find several other people who had participated in the same study Amber had." "Brandt can't give you that kind of information. It's confidential." "Yeah, but the HIV/AIDs community turns out to be a rather tight one. The people in the study knew each other, many of them, and Amber gave us some names." "Don't even tell me they confirmed her story." "No, they all said she was off her rocker. But the thing is, I did a little checking, and three of the four of them had unexplained disappearances for several days during the study period. They have no recollection of this time; in fact, most of them denied ever disappearing at all. But employers, friend and family told a different tale." "Did these people all test negative for HIV too?" "No, only one of them had his viral load down enough that it was undetectable. But I did some checking today on the names, and all four of them are still living. Lila Krunk died in 1995." "So is that where you and Diana were all day today? Checking up on these HIV patients?" "Partly." He pulled out the newspaper clipping again and handed it across to her. "But the fact that someone sent this to us -- it's got to mean something." "You're thinking maybe Brandt's car crash might not have been accident." "Think about it Scully -- based on what we've discovered, doesn't it make sense that the government might be involved in illicit immune system testing?" "Yes, of course, but that's a far cry from aliens being able to cure AIDS." Mulder swung his legs down and leaned far over the table. In a low voice, he said, "We both know that government has a vested interest in studying how to defeat viruses. I'm thinking that these desperate people would have made perfect volunteers." A sudden shooting pain behind her eyes made her suck in a breath. Pinpoints of light danced in front of her as she reached for her water. "Scully?" His voice sounded tinny and far away. "Scully, are you all right?" She pinched the bridge of her nose. "Yeah. It's nothing." Blinking rapidly to clear the spots, she braced her hands on the table. "I'm fine." "That didn't look like fine." "Ice water headache." Thank God dinner was almost over. She could go home, swallow a bunch of aspirin, and get some sleep. Mulder fished up the check, still looking unconvinced. He dropped a couple of twenties on the table and slid out of the booth. "Let's you and me blow this pop stand," he said as he slung his jacket over one shoulder. The night was dark but warm, with bone shaving moon hung high in the sky. Mulder lingered by her car. "You're sure you're okay to drive?" "Of course." He nodded a little, as if trying to convince himself. "You know, Diana and I are going to talk to Brandt widow tomorrow. Maybe you'd like to come along." "Me? I don't know the case." He gave a half shrug. "Could be good. Fresh perspective and all that." "And what am I supposed to tell Kersh?" she asked with a smile. "I was going to call in sick." "I see. And this illness of yours, is it contagious?" "Exceedingly. You don't look well, Scully. You don't look well at all." X-X-X-X-X They spread the bounty across his bed. Her hair was still damp, drying in wild tendrils around her face, and she had stripped off her wet shirt down to her bra. "It's just reams of numbers," she said, picking up the sheets nearest to her. Mulder lay sprawled at the foot of the bed with a half-dozen of the printouts in front of him. "They're tagged as the Orion project, so they must mean something." "I'm open to suggestions as to what. Did you ever have your printer go haywire and start spitting out random numbers and letters? That's what these look like to me." "Some of them have asterisks. I wonder what the significance is there." "You forgot to grab the key," she said. "I'm going to grab a water. Do you want one?" "No, thanks." He rolled onto his back and held a sheet of paper over his head. He stared at the numbers until they blurred together, but he couldn't determine a pattern. "They don't seem like social security numbers," he called out to Diana. She came back and leaned against the doorjamb, a bottle of water in her hands. "Maybe it has to do with viral load, or T-cell count, or some other immune system measure." "Good idea. We should ask the lab." "Right," she said dryly. "We just go in there and ask them to evaluate some evidence we lifted from the NIH." She was upside down from his vantage point, so he tipped his head back farther for a better view. "Okay, so maybe we don't mention where we got it." His phone rang and they both froze. "It's two AM," she said. "I realize that." "Who the hell calls at two AM?" He stretched across the bed to reach the phone. "Hello?" he said as Diana held his gaze. "Agent Mulder, this is Assistant Director Jordan. I'd apologize about calling at this late hour except for the fact that I myself was just awoken a bit ago on a matter I'm told you're familiar with." "Sir?" "Someone broke into an NIH research lab this evening." "Oh?" He sat up and put his bare feet on the floor. "Yes, Dr. Christopher Brandt's office and laboratory were both broken into, and a file cabinet was jimmied open." "That's unfortunate," Mulder replied even as his pulse thrummed in his neck. "I'm not sure how I can be of help." "Brandt mentioned your name. He said you'd been questioning him about some ridiculous rumor regarding his research. Something about aliens. I thought this couldn't possibly be true, but I want to hear your end of things." "I, uh, I have talked to Brandt about his research." "And did you in fact mention aliens?" "Sir, if you'll pardon me, I'm not really sure what my questioning Brandt about his research has to do with his lab being broken into." "I'm not sure either, but Brandt seems to think there might be a connection. He says one day you're accusing him of conducting secret human trials involving aliens, and the next thing he knows, someone is burglarizing his scientific records." "I'd have to be crazy to break into an NIH lab." "Yes, son, that's the God's-honest truth. So that's why I'm here on the phone asking you -- are you that crazy? I've heard some stories about you and your interests, and I have to say, your reputation suggests you just might have this sort of behavior in you." Mulder gave momentary thanks that he'd remembered to wear gloves. "I have no idea what Brandt is talking about." "So it's your official position that you did *not* break into Brandt's lab this evening?" "Yes, that's my position," Mulder said, going over to close the blinds. "I'll be sure to note that in my report," Jordan answered. "But don't think this matter is necessarily settled." "Sir?" "Keep your nose clean, okay? And don't be having conversations about aliens with anyone for a while." Mulder hung up the phone and Diana came around the bed to stand next to him. "What was that about?" "Brandt thinks it was me who hit the lab tonight." "I guess it's hard to fool a guy with a genius grant. Who was that on the phone?" "ADA Jordan. He recommends that I lay off the aliens for a while." "Might not be a bad idea. Brandt has friends all over this town." Mulder shook his head. "We've rattled him, and the cryptic numbers in these so-called records just make me more convinced that he's hiding something. If it's not aliens, I want to know what it is." She traced the edge of his jeans at his belly. "Even if it ends up costing you the X-files?" He gathered up the pages from the bed. "This is an X-file, the exact type of case that remains unexplained because no one wants it explained." X-X-X-X-X She tried Mulder's cell phone three more times before going to his apartment, but he did not answer. She let herself in and found it totally silent, as if he'd been gone for years. The first thing she checked was his bottom desk drawer where he usually kept his backup weapon. She was not reassured to find it missing. His bed sat unmade, his running shoes akimbo on the floor. She picked up an old T-shirt and smelled it, breathing deeply before laying it gently on the end of the bed. A quick peek at his closet told her that his suitcase was there but his duffel bag was missing. She listened to the messages on his phone, but there were two from Rivera, one from her, one from Skinner, and one from his mother. Out of all of them, his mother seemed the least concerned. "A detective contacted me this morning asking me if I knew your whereabouts, Fox. I told him you'd stopped reporting to me when you reached the age of majority. He suggested that I contact him if I heard from you in the near future, but it would probably be easiest for you to talk to him yourself." She recited Rivera's number twice, in case Mulder might have missed it. Scully found Mulder's computer asleep but not off, so she woke it up and typed in his main security password. For someone whose office and apartment were often unkempt, Mulder had a neat, almost Spartan desktop. So her stomach dropped at the sight of a word document marked "Scully." This was all the salutation she was to receive. Upon opening the file, she read the entirety of his terse message in just a few seconds: I'm sorry for the situation I've put you in, and I promise to explain as soon as I can. Do not try to contact me because it could prove dangerous for us both. It was unsigned. Scully checked the time that the file was created and determined he probably wrote it after Diana's murder. Her phone rang and she scrambled to answer it. "Hello?" she said, and held her breath. "Hello, have I reached Agent Dana Scully?" She exhaled and rubbed the ache that had formed at her forehead. "Yes, this is Dana Scully." "My name is Deborah Reddy. You left your card in my door this morning?" "Oh, Ms. Reddy, yes. Thank you for calling." "I'm sorry I wasn't there to speak to you earlier, but the police kept me for hours on end. I told them all I knew straight away, and yet they kept making me go over it and over it until I thought I'd go mad." Scully winced. "Well, I'm sorry to have to ask you to get into it again, but the FBI is conducting its own separate investigation." "Yes, I should think so, considering Agent Fowley was one of your own. I'm terribly sorry for your loss." "Thank you. If you don't mind, I'd like to start with my main question -- what made you call nine-one-one last night?" "I don't sleep so well these days, you know. Hot flashes keep me up half the night, so I was watching Conan in bed when I heard the crash outside. I might not have heard it, but I had the volume muted for the commercials. I can't stand those commercials, the way they all seem to yell at you. I just refuse to listen." Scully reined in her impatience. "So you heard a crash?" "Yes, and I went to the window and saw that Agent Mulder running towards me to a car. I didn't know his name then, but the police had me pick his face out of a group today, and they told me who he was." "So you heard the crash, you saw Agent Mulder running, and that's when you decided to call the police?" "Yes, on account of the blood." Scully's own blood froze in her veins and it took her a moment to regain her voice. "The blood?" "On Agent Mulder's shirt. He had a big stain of it right down the front of that nice white shirt." X-X-X-X-X X-X-X-X-X-X-X Chapter Three X-X-X-X-X-X-X By the time he caught up with Diana, late afternoon sun was painting streaks on her apartment walls. She stood in the bedroom, in front of the mirror, pinning up her hair. Three fat suitcases sat at the foot of the bed, and he felt the weight of them go straight to his stomach. "I guess it's true then," he said. Her reflection met Mulder's gaze as he stopped short. "Fox..." "You weren't even going to tell me?" She secured the last pin and turned around. "I wanted to, but I wasn't sure I'd be able to walk away if I had to see you again." "Well, here I am," he said, spreading his arms. "Explain it to me." "I shouldn't have to," she said as she clipped on an earring. "You know what happened with Brandt." "Diana, he has no proof! He can't force us to do anything!" "Unfortunately, the Director sees otherwise. I've been reassigned to Berlin, effective immediately." He took a step forward, blocking her path to the suitcases. "You can fight this. Brandt is making noise right now, but he knows he has no proof about the break-in. If he had any evidence, we'd both be waiting tables by now. The Director can't reassign you based on a hunch of one doctor from the NIH -- I don't care how many science fair prizes he's won." "I asked for the assignment," she replied, looking at the ground. "You...what?" "This wasn't going away. Brandt was going to keep demanding answers, and the more noise, as you put it, the more pressure on the FBI to take some sort of action, even if it's just a formal investigation." "Let them investigate. They won't find anything." "Don't you see? God, Fox, for someone so smart, you can be dumb politically. They don't want to open the X-files. They'd just like it even less if you were to leave the Bureau entirely, so they're humoring you in the hopes that you'll wake up and go back VCU in a few months." Mulder blew out a frustrated breath. He wasn't blind to politics; he was above them. "You think I don't know that? I know damn well that I'm the blue chip here, and they're just trying to keep me happy. That's even more reason for us to fight this crap from Brandt." She shook her head slowly. "You're still not getting it. Brandt wants some sort of action here, some sort of demonstration from the FBI that we're no longer going to be a problem. Sending one of us three thousand miles away is an excellent show of concern and support for Brandt's point. The men upstairs don't give a rat's ass whether we're guilty or not, although between you and me, I think ADA Jordan knows the truth of it. If he could prove it, we might both have a one-way ticket to Germany." "I can't believe you'd give up this easily," Mulder said in disgust as he turned away. "Hey, I did this for you," she replied as she spun him around again. "Like hell you did. First sign of trouble, and you're out of here." "They were sending one of us -- you or me -- one of us was getting on that plane." He searched her face and she nodded shortly. "I can't run the X-Files," she said at length, her voice rough with regret. "It's not my project to begin with, and it's not fair that they try to hand it to me. That would be as good as killing it." "They wanted to send me," said Mulder as realization slowly dawned. Diana said nothing. Outside, a car horn beeped three times. "That's my cab." "Diana--" She shushed him by placing her fingers over his mouth. "I'll be back, right? This isn't forever. We just need some time to lay low for a while and then I can return. You'll have the X-files going, and we can deal from a position of strength." He kissed her fingertips and squeezed his eyes shut. "You can't actually be leaving," he whispered. Alone with his monsters, ghosts and extra-terrestrials, he thought he might go mad. When everyone around you says the spooks are all in your head, you start to believe it. She smiled at him sadly and kissed him on the cheek. "Walk me out," she said as the taxi horn beeped again. Mulder hoisted the strap from one bag over his shoulder and picked up the other with his hand. Diana took the smallest and they left the apartment together, the door clicking shut behind them. He felt a familiar outline as her carryon bumped against his ribcage. "What's in here?" he asked at the elevator. "Just some files." "Our files?" "Not really. I won't be doing this kind of work in Berlin, so I won't be needing them. Fox, don'tŠ" The elevator dinged as he withdrew the folders from the side of her bag. "These are the papers from Brandt's office." "I'm just taking them with me for your safety," she said, removing them from his hand. "You just said you're not going to be working these kinds of cases." He yanked the file back. "And I can't believe you were just going to take it." "Fox, listen to me," she said, her voice low and urgent. "If you get caught with this stuff, it's over. I don't care what kind of Wonder Boy you are, they will kick you out so far, you won't hit ground until Boise. They'll bring charges of federal trespassing, theft, possibly espionage and treason." "How am I supposed to find out what's going on if you take all the evidence with you?" he asked as he followed her into the elevator. She leaned against the side, looking tired. "I think you should drop this case for now. Maybe come back to it later. You have a whole file cabinet of unexplained cases demanding your attention, and this one is perhaps just a little too hot at the moment." "All the more reason to push it." He looked down at the strings of numbers but they made no more sense this time than the other ten thousand times he'd studied them. "I'm going to be working foreign intelligence," she said. "They have some of the best code breakers in the world over there. Let me see if I can show this around -- quietly, of course -- and maybe we'll get some answers about what it might mean." Mulder closed the folder but kept it pressed against his stomach. "I don't know." "Fine," she said with a sigh as the doors slid open. "Suit yourself. But if I were you, I'd keep that file buried deep until Brandt stops jawing in the Director's ear. If he convinces them to search your place..." "Take it," he answered, shoving the file at her. "Let me know what you can find out." She smiled as she tucked the file back in the bag that hung from his shoulder. The movement jostled them close together. "Is that Mulder-speak for 'call me'?" she asked. "Just keep in mind that my line might be bugged," he said, only half-teasing. The taxi driver came to load her suitcases into the car. "Does that mean no phone sex?" she breathed near Mulder's ear. "Only if you're into threesomes." "Kinky." "Quite. At least we'd be able to access the transcripts for posterity." "No more illegal break-ins for a while, hmm?" She pressed her lips to his, and he grabbed the back of her head. They kissed until the driver interrupted with a not-so-subtle cough. "Call me," he said, this time for real. "I will." She rode off in the direction of the low, setting sun, causing Mulder to shield his eyes from the glare. It was the last time he saw or talked to her again for almost six years. X-X-X-X-X Scully's eyes were pinched and dry, and a throbbing had started at her temples. She couldn't remember the last time she'd had anything to eat, her stomach felt like a shriveled orange at her middle. She expected to find Skinner at his office despite the late hour, and indeed light slanted out from underneath the closed door. She didn't bother to knock. "I need to see the results of the autopsy," she said as she entered. Skinner had a scotch in front of him. "They won't even let me near the results of that autopsy. You don't have a chance." "We have to find a way. Something about this whole story just doesn't make sense to me. That trashcan Mulder supposedly knocked over was totally out of position. I find it just a little too convenient that he managed to topple it right underneath the street light and make a racket good enough to be heard from the neighbors." "You think he was set up?" "I think he set himself up. For some reason, Mulder was trying to draw attention to himself. If he'd just killed Diana Fowley, why would he do that?" Skinner rubbed the lip of his glass with one finger. "I don't know. But if he'd just walked in and found her body, why wouldn't he just call it in?" "I don't know," Scully admitted as she sank into one of the chairs. "But he must have his reasons. Maybe if we got a look at the autopsy report, we could get an idea about what's going on." "Gun shot to the head," Skinner said, sounding fatigued. "I don't think there's a lot of mystery there." "I want to see it anyway." "I make no promises. This show still belongs to the local boys, and they're not eager to let us play a part. I think Rivera half believes that we have Mulder hiding out in the basement here." "I looked. He's not there." Skinner widened his eyes at her, and she shrugged. "It was worth a try." "You know," said Skinner, "I can help you more if you tell me what was going on between them." "I'm not sure I knew," she said. "Were they sleeping together?" Scully considered her words carefully. "Whatever happened tonight, you can be sure it wasn't because of sex." "There are only three great motives, Agent Scully -- love, money and revenge. One of them must have killed her." "I think, sir, that in the end it may have been all three." X-X-X-X-X In Mulder's car, Scully noticed that the passenger seat, her seat, had been altered to fit someone with much longer legs. "So what exactly did you and Diana do yesterday?" she asked as she fixed the seat. "Not a lot. We went to the scene of Brandt's accident. There were no skid marks that we could see, but of course that's not conclusive. It was raining the night of the crash, so it's possible there wouldn't even be marks." When they pulled up to the Darjeeling Cafe, they found Diana sitting outside with a newspaper, an espresso, and a cigarette. She extinguished her smoke as they approached and tucked away her Washington Post. "A bad habit I picked up in Europe," she said with a touch of embarrassment. "You can't sit at a cafe there without one, or everyone guesses you're American." Mulder took the chair closest to her and Scully dragged one of the white metal seats from another table. "Coffee?" Diana asked them. "I can also vouch for the raspberry croissant." Scully had skipped breakfast because her stomach wasn't feeling well, but the smell of the strong coffee made it grumble. "I'll have both," she said, and Mulder gave her a look of surprise. "Nothing for me." He still wore his sunglasses despite the shade of the large striped umbrella. "What did you find out from the coroner?" "They wouldn't give me a copy of the report, but he told me basically what was in it. Christopher Brandt died of internal bleeding as a result of his car accident. His abdominal aorta was punctured, and the M.E. says he would have died almost immediately." "What punctured it?" Scully asked, leaning back so the waiter could put her food in front of her. "Looks like the gearshift snapped off and he was impaled on the remainder, but that's just a guess right now. He wasn't wearing a belt." "What about the car? Any evidence that it was tampered with?" Mulder wanted to know. "They're still picking pieces of it back out of the valley. But my understanding is that they're leaning toward calling it an accident. Brandt's blood alcohol was point two -- twice the legal limit." She picked up her cup and drained the last of her coffee. "Apparently, Brandt had a reputation as a drinker and was stopped a couple of years ago on a DUI. Someone made it go away, though, because he was never charged." "I don't understand then," Scully said. "What are we hoping to get out of the widow?" Mulder scooped up Diana's paper from where she had set it aside. "Right here on page four," he said, pointing. "Imogene Brandt says she thinks her husband was murdered." Scully took another small sip of coffee. So far, her stomach was not objecting. "Does she why she thinks this?" "She said he was involved in highly controversial research," answered Diana as she signaled for the check. "Seeing as how that was our opinion seven years ago," Mulder said, "we'd like to know more." Scully reached for her wallet to contribute her share, but Diana waved her off. "My treat," she said with an even smile. Scully left half the croissant uneaten. Imogene Brandt also had an office at the NIH, although she maintained a research lab at NASA and an emeritus professorship at Cornell University. Her secretary let them in, and she joined them in the living area of her large office. She had a shock of short, white hair, a bright magenta blouse and a black pencil skirt. As she sat in high-backed end chair, she took off her glasses and blinked owlishly at them. "I remember Christopher talking about you two," she said to Mulder and Diana. "He had half a mind to sue your whole agency." "That was a misunderstanding," Diana said. "Poppycock. My late husband might have been a fool sometimes, but he didn't misunderstand much." She frowned at Scully. "You, I'm not familiar with." "My name is Dana Scully. I was a big fan of your husband's work. We studied his seminal findings on natural killer T cells in medical school." "You could fill ten text books with his work. Who knows what we've lost with his death -- a cure for AIDS would be just the tip of it. He was unlocking the major mysteries of the immune system. What makes it turn on itself? Why does it become less effective with age? After nearly forty years of marriage, I can understand the murderous impulses, but killing Chris would be taking thousands, maybe millions, of lives with him." "Did you collaborate with your husband?" Scully asked. "Lord, no. We both knew better. Thank goodness our research interests were far enough apart that we were never even tempted. He left me to my quantum mechanics; I left him to his viruses. We did used to get a laugh sometimes out of the fact that we both studied entities no one could see." "What exactly is your area of research?" asked Mulder as he leaned forward. "String theory, at the moment." Mulder looked at Scully for help. "Isn't that sometimes called 'The Theory of Everything'?" Imogene answered for her. "Indeed it is," she said, arching an eyebrow. "I would often kid Christopher that his nothings were contained in my nothings, so he should just sit around and wait for me to finish first." "I'm not sure I follow," Mulder said. Scully had an inkling now of why she'd been invited along. "String theory is designed to explain the movement of all particles in the universe," she said. "Current laws only hold if you set aside gravity." "I'm pretty sure gravity exists," replied Mulder as he looked at his feet. "That's why we need new theories," Imogene said. "The problem is that the strings are too small to be studied empirically, so we've got to test other theories that are premised either on their existence or lack thereof. My work is also controversial, but the only ones debating it are snooty scientists wearing bowties and thick glasses. Chris got death threats from people who thought he was interfering with God's plan." "God's plan?" Diana asked. "You mean AIDS?" "AIDS and other illnesses, yes. Certain religious groups took issue with his work because he often included homosexuals, drug addicts, and other social undesirables in his research. Tax dollars shouldn't go to support these kind of 'alternative' lifestyles, don't you know." "You think someone killed him because of his work?" Mulder asked. "I think it's possible. I don't care what the police say about Christopher and his drinking. He knew his limits." "Dr. Brandt," Diana said, "he had high levels of alcohol in his blood when he died." "Yes, they told me his levels. Christopher probably woke up every day with a BAC of zero point two. That wouldn't be enough to get him even slightly knackered behind the wheel." "These threats your husband was getting," Mulder said, "had they escalated recently? Are there any that stand out in particular?" "Talk to his secretary, Marian Ellsbury. She kept the complete file. You might ask her also about Chris's current bed partners -- perhaps she maintains that list as well." "Excuse me?" Mulder said. "Chris's appetite for knowledge was surpassed only by one other hunger, and he indulged early and often in the female buffet. I found the first one before we'd even married. He promised he'd change, but I knew better." She shrugged. "I married him anyway." "If you don't mind me asking," Scully said, "why?" "I knew I was never going to meet another man as brilliant as Chris. That kind of brainpower, it's like being in the room with a giant vibrator." Diana coughed, and Mulder hid a grin. "You think I'm joking," Imogene said. "Women didn't go to bed with him for his looks." "We'll, um, look into that angle," Mulder said. "Any idea who he might have been seeing lately?" Imogene rubbed her eyes with one hand. "I tried not to know, if you get the picture, and Chris did his best to allow me my ignorance. Last year he wrote a grant with Kendra Thompson at the VA, and I suspect some of their meetings were less than scientifically oriented. I overheard him ordering flowers for her birthday." "Kendra Thompson," Mulder said. "Got it." He paused and shifted on the couch. "Dr. Brandt, it might help us in our investigation if we had access to your husband's research files." "You mean to check for any aliens on the roster?" She sat up with a sigh. "I know a little bit about you and your work, Agent Mulder. It's partially why I agreed to this meeting, because I know you're persistent. The police seem willing to dismiss Christopher's accident as just that. If you investigate and reach the same conclusions as they do, I'll have to accept the findings. But this idea you seem to have that my husband was involved with extra-terrestrial research... well, it's preposterous, really. There is doubtless intelligent life elsewhere in the universe, but the notion that they could come here only to collaborate in total secret with our government sounds like something only a paranoid schizophrenic patient could dream up." "So I'm guessing that's a no on the research?" Mulder asked. "Even if I wanted to help you, I couldn't. I have no access to his files, and I'm not a collaborator on any of his research. I've no claim to his data." "Then I'm not sure we have the time to help you," Mulder answered. "Look, the police don't know what my husband was doing on that road, or where he'd been that he'd had those drinks. They are mildly curious about the answers, but I get the distinct impression they won't be looking too hard for them. You, on the other hand, don't seem to stop until you have answers, and I know from second-hand experience that you'll do whatever it takes to get them. I want to know where my husband was and what he was doing the night he was killed." "You realize this isn't federal investigation," Diana said. "We have no official authority to investigate your husband's death." "That doesn't seem to have stopped you in the past." "Dr. Brandt," Diana began to protest, but the woman dismissed her with a wave of her hand. "Ancient history as far as I'm concerned." After they left, they stood around in the hot, sun-drenched parking lot and compared notes. "I can't tell if she believes we owe her one because she thinks we broke into her husband's office," Mulder said, "or whether she's under the impression that the FBI is a private investigation unit for all government employees." "You think her suspicions about Brandt's death are correct?" Diana asked. "I haven't the slightest idea. All I know is that it's the first window into this case we've had in seven years." "What case? The alien research angle again?" "You and I both know that something was hinky with Brandt back then. I don't know what exactly he was up to, but I think it's at least as likely that he got killed for his back alley research than by some jealous lover or religious kook." Diana lowered her sunglasses a bit and looked at him. "Okay, I'll handle the jealous lover angle, see if I can get a handle on whom he might have been seeing." Mulder looked at Scully. "Guess that leaves us with the kooks." "You mean we're not going to start with the alien collaborators?" "You know, that's not a bad idea." "I was kidding." "Yeah, but it's still not a bad idea." He turned to Diana. "Those papers we got from Brandt's lab -- we should let Scully take a look at them to see if she can figure out what they mean. Maybe there's a pattern there that will make sense to her as a doctor that we couldn't see." "Sure," Diana said. "Why not? Let her take a look." "Are they back in the basement with the others?" She flicked a bug off her arm. "What do you mean?" "The papers. You took them with you." "I did? I don't think so." Mulder took off his shades and squinted at her. "Yeah, you took them when you left because we were concerned I might get searched." "Fox, I don't remember any of this. I haven't seen those papers in years." "You lost them?" he asked, incredulous. "I don't think I ever had them." "You had them," he said. "Check the files and I bet they turn up." "I'll check, but I swear to you I haven't seen them in ages." Mulder shook his head as if clearing it. "You look and I'll look too. Maybe I have a copy someplace." In the car, Mulder didn't immediately start the engine. He watched Diana get in her Nissan, back out, and leave the parking lot. "She took the files with her," he murmured to Scully. "It was a long time ago," Scully said, and Mulder turned on the car. "I remember it like it was yesterday," he said, and Scully pictured the long goodbye. He turned and looked at her. "It's the only time I ever let an X-file get away." X-X-X-X-X She drove with the windows down, the damp night air breezing in to keep her awake. Her veins were half-filled with coffee and she had the radio on low just in case the news reports had any updates on the Fowley case. Every hour or so, she tried Mulder's cell phone. When his voice mail came on for the zillionth time, she flung the phone across the passenger seat. She took a hard right, exiting from the highway at the last minute. It was past midnight when she reached her destination, but she didn't even pause to think before she rang the buzzer. "I know you're in there," she yelled at the camera as she banged on the heavy front door. "Open up." Static crackled from the intercom. "Agent Scully," Byers said. "What are you doing out so late?" "Let me in," she said. The intercom snapped off, and after a few more seconds, she pounded on the door again. "Listen, Scully, he's not here." This time it was Frohike on the line. "We don't know where he is." "Right," she shouted into the speaker. "You know he's missing, but you haven't had any contact with him." "He's not here," Frohike repeated. "And I swear to you we don't know where he is." "Let me in." She wanted to see them lie to her face. "No can do. Sorry." "Mulder?" She braced a hand on either side of the intercom. "Mulder, can you hear me?" "Scully, we wouldn't lie to you," Byers said. "Mulder is not here." "Then let me in." She heard some unintelligible chatter and the intercom switched off once more. Her heart thudded in her throat as she waited, but the door didn't open. "What the hell is going on here? Why won't you let me in?" She was half tempted to take out her gun and shoot the door down, but the gunmen had more locks than she had bullets. At last, the steel drawer in the door slid open. She peered inside and found a cell phone, which seemed to be on. She picked it up and held it to her ear without saying anything. "Scully?" "Mulder!" Her knees went out and she sagged against the building. "What's going on? Where are you?" "I'm just trying to figure things out. Are you okay?" "Me? I'm not the one who ran from a murder." "I can explain, but not right now." "Mulder, I need to talk to you." She turned around so the guys could not read her lips on the monitor or hear her through the intercom. "The police are looking for you." "I figured as much. Don't worry, I'm okay for now. I just have to stay out of sight for a while until I can get some things straightened out." "What things? Tell me where you are. I can help you." "I can't," he said, sounding genuinely regretful. "It's too dangerous." "Dangerous how? Do you know who killed Diana?" "No." He paused, and his voice took on an odd tone. "Do you?" "They won't let me near the investigation, Mulder, but I'm pretty sure your name is at the top of the suspect list." "What did you tell them?" "Nothing, of course. But the detective in charge, Rivera, he knows about your fight with her. He just doesn't know what caused it." "Keep it that way." "I'm trying." She clutched the phone tighter and swallowed the lump in her throat. "Mulder, please let me help you." "You are. Just...just keep doing what you're doing. Don't give the cops any help at all. And leave the guys alone, okay? They don't know anything, and you're scaring Frohike." "They knew how to contact you." "I'll give you this number and then you can know too." He recited a foreign number, but the small victory was not enough. "Mulder, if you did this because of me, because of what happened, maybe we can find a way out. Diana was no innocent victim." "That's not going to matter right now." "Why?" "Trust me. It's more complicated than you know." "So tell me," she begged. "I can't help you otherwise." "I have to go, Scully." "No, Mulder, wait." "What?" She wanted to ask him a million questions. Do you have enough to eat? Are you safe? Did you really do it? Instead, she said nothing. "Yeah," he answered at last. "Me too." "Be careful," she whispered. "You too." He clicked off and she held the phone between her breasts, head tipped back against the wall. The intercom came to life again, and she vaguely heard Byers calling her. "Agent Scully? Are you okay? Scully?" She placed the phone back in the drawer and walked away. X-X-X-X-X X-X-X-X-X-X-X- Chapter Four X-X-X-X-X-X-X The first time he met Diana was not at work but in a bar. It was a hot August night and his air conditioning was on the fritz, so he set up shop at the local pub with a pint of Guinness, a dish of nuts, and a Braves-Phillies game on the TV. Diana was pregnant with another man's baby, although he didn't know it at the time, and it was for this reason she sought him out. She came right up and sat next to him, her painted nails wrapped around a seltzer and lime. "You're Fox Mulder," she said. "I'd introduce myself but I'm quite sure you already know who I am." He crunched a nut and looked her over, trying to decide whether to play dumb or not. "I've heard that nothing much escapes you," she said before he could commit. "I've seen you around," he said at last. "You're from SIOC, right?" "Since the beginning -- all ten months of it." She reached into his nut bowl and helped herself. "But after the inauguration, things have been a little slow. I might be looking to shift departments soon to someplace more challenging." "Oh, yeah? You have any one in particular in mind?" She slipped a peanut between her lips. "VCU seems interesting, fast-paced. I was a criminology minor in school, so the casework would be interesting to me. Do you like it?" "It pays the bills." He sneaked a look at the TV screen in time to see the Braves pull ahead two-to-one. "Now you're just being modest. That spree killer in Louisiana -- what was his name, Jefferson? -- I heard they brought you in to help question the witnesses and you solved the case in twenty-four hours." "I didn't solve it, the witnesses did." "But they didn't know what they'd seen until you showed them," she said, admiration plain in her voice. Mulder didn't reply, instead gathering another handful of nuts. "I was wondering about SAC Burkit. Is he a good guy to work for?" He stopped crunching and looked at her again. She was busy stirring all the carbonation out of her drink. SIOC agents did not cross his path very often, so the place where he'd "seen her around" was in the parking garage, with Tom Burkit's tongue in her mouth. "He's okay," Mulder said, and took a sip of his beer. "Really? Because before I make any decisions about jumping departments, I want to be sure I'm entering into a good situation." Burkit was married with three kids. Mulder couldn't speak from experience, but he was reasonably convinced that this did not have the makings of a good situation. The intriguing part was why she was asking him about it. "What specifically did you want to know?" "Just general aspects of his personality, anything you might have picked up from working with him that I should know about." Mulder sighed and pushed his beer away. "Burkit is your classic over-achiever with a self-loathing twist. Everything came early and easy to him. He graduated college in three years, got a Masters in criminal psych and was recruited aggressively by the FBI because he speaks German, two dialects of Chinese and a little bit of Russian. He wears a cross around his neck for luck from God, and the thing is, he believes he needs it. Burkit works his tail off because he's never quite sure he's good enough. He respects those who work hard for him but he becomes alarmed if you seem too good, too fast. He doesn't trust his own ability, so when he sees those qualities in others, he doesn't trust them either." "You make him nervous," Diana surmised. "Yeah, I bet nowhere near as nervous as you make him." Her smile froze and she clutched her glass. "You know," she said, and bowed her head. "Not really my business," he said, "at least until you came here to make it mine." "I'm sorry, really. I just saw you sitting here, and I thought..." He waited with his pint halfway to his mouth. "What?" "You're renown for your insight into human behavior, so I thought maybe you could see something in him that I don't, maybe give me some perspective." "What is it you really want to know?" Diana hesitated. "God, I can't even say it." Mulder found he knew anyway. "He's not going to leave her," he said quietly, and Diana's head jerked up. "You're sure." "You can never be totally sure, but yeah, I'm pretty sure. I don't think he wants another reason to hate himself." "God," she said, covering her face with her hands. "When you put it that way... Christ. What the hell am I going to do?" Mulder had the answer to almost anything, but not this. "Do you think other people know?" she asked him. "I think if you don't want them to know, you should consider waiting until you're off FBI property before going at it." "You're right. Of course, you're right." Her shoulders drooped. "I think maybe part of me wanted it to get out. Maybe then he'd make up his mind." She glanced at Mulder hopefully. "Listen," he said, turning on the stool toward her. "I don't know you and I'm not judging you, but there's one thing you should know: Burkit's mind is made up already. If you corner him, I promise you won't like the results." "You're saying he'd stay with door number one," she said with a heavy sigh. "I get it. Thanks." The Phillies' catcher singled to drive in two runs and put them back on top again, and Mulder ordered another beer. "Can I buy you something stronger?" he asked, eyeing Diana's tonic. "I don't think I ought to be drinking right now," she said. "I'm an armed FBI agent, you know." "Another tonic and lime for the lady," Mulder told the bartender. "On me." "You're far too nice. Here you were, enjoying a quiet night and a baseball game, and I came over here and regurgitated my problems all over your lap." "Thanks for that image." "Sorry," she said again. "I should be the one buying you the drinks." "You can get the next round." She perked up a bit at the realization he wasn't going to kick her out. "I won't bug you anymore. I promise." She sipped her drink and stretched over to see the monitor. "What quarter is it?" "It's the sixth inning," Mulder answered, amused. "Right, of course." She lifted her thick hair off the back of her nape. Mulder couldn't help but ogle -- she gave great neck. "I know the A/C is on, but it can't ever be cool enough for me." He drank down a quarter of his new beer and licked the foam from his lips. "You know, if you're actually serious about wanting to move into VCU, there might be an opening soon." "You mean after I shoot Burkit's balls off?" He grinned and ducked his head. "Yeah, definitely after that, because I'm not leaving before a show like that one." "You're leaving?" she asked, her eyes wide. "To go where?" He wasn't sure how much to tell her, but the beer helped. "I'm thinking of starting a new department," he said. "One focused on the unexplained." They talked for more than three hours, with Diana doing most of the listening. She kissed his cheek when she left, and two weeks later, it was Mulder who went with her to the clinic to have an abortion. X-X-X-X Diana materialized almost from nowhere when they arrived at the NIH. She approached them as they were getting out of the car and gave a little wave. "Brings back memories," she said to Mulder, touching his arm. "I'm happy enough to use the front door this time," he said. "We should get going," Scully said. "We have to be back before Kersh misses us." Diana lowered her shades and peered at Scully. "I was thinking about that, and I thought maybe you two would prefer it if I took the lead on this. I can run down the leads from the secretary with no problems, but you might come under scrutiny." "That won't be necessary," Mulder told her. "We're just suckers for scrutiny." "I just don't want you to get into any trouble." Mulder grinned. "Now where's the fun in that?" He touched Diana's back and started for the main entrance. Christopher Brandt's secretary, Marian Ellsbury, let them into his large office upstairs from the lab. For Mulder, it was a little too close to returning to the scene of the crime. He focused on the framed photos on the wall, which included what looked like an original Picasso pen-and-ink drawing of a nude woman and an old photo from the Holocaust, depicting an old man with his head bent and a ramshackle dwelling and barbed wire behind him. "I've been so busy these last few days," Marian was saying as she ushered them to a low-backed leather sofa. "I've cancelled all his trips, his speaking engagements, his charity events -- everyone's heard the news already but I have to be sure. The thing is, when I'm done putting all his affairs in order, there'll be nothing left for me to do here." She paused and folded her hands in her lap. "I've been with Dr. Brandt for twenty years. I hardly know what to do with myself now." "We're very sorry for your loss," Scully said. "It's not just my loss. The world should be in mourning today." "Dr. Brandt's wife said you might be able to help us with the names of people who had made threats against him recently," said Mulder. "You believe this wasn't an accident?" She looked from one to the other of them. "I thought Imogene was just speaking out of grief and anger. I had no idea the police were considering it anything more than an accident." "The police aren't considering it," Diana told her. "That's why we're here. Do you know where Dr. Brandt was coming from the night he was killed?" "No, I've already told the police that. His appointment schedule was clear. He left a little early that day, around five, but he didn't say where he was going. He just wished me goodnight and said he'd see me in the morning. I found out he'd died when I arrived to put on the coffee and found an officer standing at my desk." "That must have been terrible for you," Mulder said. "It was..." She stopped and checked herself, looking at him more closely. "Wait, what did you say your name was again?" "Actually, I didn't say." Mulder had managed not to be introduced. "But my name is Agent Mulder." "Mulder, that's right, I thought you seemed familiar. You're the one who broke into our lab!" Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Scully stiffen. "No, I don't think so," he said to Marian. "Yes, you're the one. I remember now. You accused him of conducting research with aliens!" "I never accused him of anything," Mulder said mildly. "I was merely asking questions based on what we'd been told." "Based on the word of crazy people! Is that why you're here now? You think that since he's gone you can come back and sully his work again with more insane accusations?" "We're here at the request of his widow," Diana interjected. "I don't believe it." "Call her and ask," Scully suggested, and Marian got up to go do just that. "Imogene, it's Marian. I have three FBI agents here, and--" She stopped as Imogene Brandt said something on the other end. "You did? Do you know who these people are? I don't think Chris would appreciate them coming around like this, not after what happened." She listened again, and then her tone became quite chilly. "I see. Yes. Yes, of course. It's your decision." She placed the phone gently back in the cradle and then rejoined the group, but she did not sit down. "Dr. Brandt asks that I give you any help I can in finding out what happened to her husband." "It's very kind of her to be so loyal," Mulder said, "given that the other Dr. Brandt didn't seem to return the favor." "Just what are you suggesting?" "Imogene Brandt told us that Christopher had affairs throughout their marriage," Scully said, not unkindly. "She also said you might be able to tell us his current partner." Marian pursed her lips. "I can't believe she'd up and tell you such things. They have always been such private people." "Death has a way of ripping off the veil of secrecy," Mulder answered. "It wasn't so much secret," Marian said, seeming tired now. "Yes, he had his dalliances, but he kept them quiet out of respect for Imogene. He would never have done anything willingly to hurt her. She knew he would always come back, and he always did." "Maybe she got tired of looking the other way," Diana suggested. To Mulder's surprise, Marian didn't launch into an angry defense. She picked at the piping on the upholstered chair and brushed away imaginary lint. "I expect it was tiresome for Imogene at times, but I think she was inured to it by now." "Any idea who the current woman was?" Diana asked. "No, if there was someone current, I didn't know about it. But mind you he kept me in the dark when he could help it. He knows I'm on friendly terms with Imogene and that I talk to her daily. He didn't want to put me in the position of having to lie to her, so he often made arrangements on his own. "Arrangements?" said Scully. Marian hesitated a moment. "For hotels and the like. The last woman I think he may have been with was his previous collaborator, Kendra Thompson. But I was under the impression that the affair had cooled last spring." "Where do *you* think he was going the night of his death?" "I confess I did entertain the idea that he might have found someone new. He seemed distracted lately, and that's often a sign. I don't have any names; it's just a feeling." She halted, apparently torn about whether to go on. "You have an idea about where he was," Mulder said. "Not an idea. More like an inkling. Dr. Brandt had several hotels that he favored, and two of them were up in that region." "We'll need the names," Diana said. "And the names of the people who were threatening him," Mulder added. As Marian went to comply with their requests, he turned to Scully. "Placing any bets on motive?" he whispered to her. "Statistically, more people are killed over sex than over ideology," she replied. "And if he was truly meeting someone in a hotel that night, I'm guessing it wasn't a lunatic protestor. But Mulder, we haven't even discovered conclusive evidence that Brandt was actually murdered." "He was up to something." "You're just saying that because of what happened before," she replied under her breath. "Admit it, you're still working the alien angle here, Mulder. We may be chasing nothing more than a tragic car accident." But later, as they drove home, he kept an eye on the rearview mirror and noticed a black Lexus with tinted windows dogging them at a distance. "We may have company," he said to Scully, and she turned around to look. "He's been with us since we left the lab." "Who do you think it is?" "Don't know, but five'll get you ten that it's not an alien." X-X-X-X Most of the time, guns were nothing special to her. Scully grew up with guns in the house, with her Navy captain father's collection in his den and her brothers' BB rifles in the backyard. She'd learned to shoot by kindergarten and had passed the Academy certification program on the first try. Her FBI-issued automatic was a tool, a familiar weight on her body, and she respected its authority. In medical school, though, she found most students and doctors didn't share her tolerance for guns. To them, guns were sucking chest wounds, shattered bones and pierced organs. Guns were the metallic scent of blood, the lifeless eyes of the dead, and the screams of agony from family members left behind. Guns turned a human being into one hundred and eighty pounds of meat. She closed one eye and squinted with the other, focusing on the shadowed outline in the distance. At this moment, she didn't even see the gun anymore, could only feel the warm steel in her hands. Her finger squeezed the trigger. An explosion of sound ricocheted around the room as the recoil traveled back up her arms. Five bullets, center mass. She lowered the gun and was about to hit the button for a new target when someone else reached from behind and did it for her. She whirled to find Mulder standing there wearing earphones and safety glasses. As the paper target floated up to them, he unhooked it and took off his eyewear. "Not bad, Scully. If you'd just moved this one a little to the left, the holes would be a smiley face. See?" She took the paper from him. "What are you doing here?" "It's about the only place I know to find you these days. What is this, your third time this week?" "I was at my desk all afternoon. Where were you?" She took out the empty clip and replaced it with a new one. "Following up on the list of death threats given to us by Christopher Brandt's secretary." He extracted a folded-up piece of paper from his jacket pocket. "According to her, the guy at the top of the list is a loner named Keton LaRue. He's not part of any organization, but they've caught him twice spray painting epithets on the outside of the lab. He apparently believes that AIDS is God's scourge on the unclean, and that any efforts to combat the disease is akin to singing on with the devil." "Charming," Scully said as she tucked her gun back in its holster. "Yeah, tell me about it. The only problem with LaRue as a suspect is that he's never really threatened violence against Brandt personally. He's called him a bunch of names and vowed to burn down the lab, but mostly his letters are of the 'God will make you pay for this' variety." "Maybe he got tired of waiting for God to step in." "Yeah, I don't recall anything about Œthou shalt not question the Almighty's timetable' on the stone tablets." He refolded the paper and gestured with it toward the shooting range. "So what's with the sudden interest in artillery? Do you have plans to shoot anyone in particular, and if so, would I be safer back behind the lead doors?" She shrugged. "I like coming here. It helps me think." The truth was actually the opposite -- shooting helped her *not* to think. It was amazing how much one could block out when one had to concentrate on placing bullets where one wanted them. In the past year, she had been nearly dead three times; twice he'd managed to save her and the third was a point they had agreed not to talk about. In fact, so adept were they at not talking, that they had managed to reach this agreement without even discussing it. "Thinking about anything in particular?" he asked, totally in violation of their unspoken rules. He folded his arms across his chest and lounged against the half-wall. "No, not especially." He nodded to himself and then focused on the floor. "You know, I've never been really good at dates, but around November, I get really bad. I'll go to write a check and honestly have no idea what day to put on it -- is it early in the month? Late? I have to check my watch every time, sometimes several times in one day. It's like my brain deals with the anniversary of Samantha's disappearance by actively suppressing the date." "This is September, Mulder," she said. "I know," he replied, with a ghost of a smile. "My brain has no problems with September." "Good," she replied, and reached for her goggles and headset. "But I was outside this morning," he continued, and she forced herself not to roll her eyes as she stopped and waited for him to go on. "And it smelled like fall for the first time. You know the way the air starts to smell cool, like it has an edge to it? The sky turns a clear, bright blue, and you just know that somewhere, someone is burning a pile of dead leaves." "It is officially fall now," she pointed out, "so it only makes sense." "Yeah, but that smell, it was so strong it stopped me right on the sidewalk, and then I finally realized why." She waited, and he raised his eyes to look at her. "It was the same smell a year ago," he said, "when I was going in and out of Trinity Hospital." Her instinct was to look away, but she held his gaze and let him study her. "Yes, I guess it was," she said at last. "So that red mark on your calendar -- it's a checkup?" "Uh, yes," she said, blowing out a long breath. "Just a chance to look under the hood, so to speak, and make sure everything's still running. My blood work was clean six months ago, so I don't expect anything different this time." "Nothing to worry about, then." "Nothing at all." She forced a smile. "In fact, assuming everything goes okay, they may enroll me in a new study on patients who achieve spontaneous remission from late stage cancers." "A chance to make the record books," Mulder said as he followed her back outside to the main desk, where they returned their protective equipment. "I haven't decided whether to do it," she answered. "I'm all for the advancement of science, but I don't necessarily want to sign on for lengthy bouts of more testing." He caught the main door over her head with his fingertips, and she walked out underneath his arm. The sun had just slipped below the horizon, deepening the starless sky to purple, and with its exit came a cool night breeze. "You never know, Scully," he said as they walked to her car. "This could be your chance to get some answers." She clicked the locks open. "I thought about that part, and I guess I'm not convinced that the answers I'm seeking will come from a government-funded study." He gave her a delighted grin. "Scully, is that paranoid anti-government, distrust of authority I hear in your tone? It just goes to show -- you can take the girl out of the X- files, but not the X-files out of the girl." Her fingers automatically went to the base of her neck. "Yeah, I guess so," she said, and his humor faded. He nudged her with his foot. "It's past seven. Want to get dinner?" "Dinner two nights in one week?" she asked. "What's the occasion?" "All-you-can-eat wings at the Naked Armadillo." "Pass," she said, turning back to her car. "Aw, come on, Scully -- ladies drink for free." She hesitated with her hand on the door latch. A drink and dinner with Mulder was certainly better than going back to her apartment alone with her thoughts. "Well, maybe just for a while," she said. "Great," he replied. "You can buy me a beer." This time she did roll her eyes as she suppressed a smile. She was about to ask where this Armadillo place was when Mulder's cell phone rang. "Just a sec," he said to her as he dug it out. "Yeah, Mulder." He paused to listen and then turned his back to her. "How important?" she heard him ask. He checked his watch. "Yeah, I know where that is. Okay. No, no, I won't. Stay put and I'll see you in about a half an hour." "I guess dinner is off," she said when he faced her again. "Yeah, sorry. We can go next week." He was already walking way towards his car. "Everything all right?" He looked back over his shoulder. "Sure, fine. I, uh... I've just got to take care of something right away. See you tomorrow, okay?" Scully didn't bother to reply because there was no way he would have heard her. She stood hugging her open car door, watching as he drove off into traffic. The glowing orb of the moon now hung low and large in the sky, but its pull was no match for whatever body had Mulder swept up in its orbit. X-X-X-X Scully meant to go home but somehow found herself parked in front of Mulder's apartment building. The street was silent and all the windows dark. She rode up to the sound of the old squeaking elevator and dug out the key to see what was behind door number forty-two. The fish tank burbled softly in the back, and she followed the light across the room. His fish nipped and tucked in the water, swishing violently in their efforts to convey their hunger. Scully obliged them by sprinkling in some flakes, and then watched as they gobbled them all down. The red light on his machine was unblinking, signaling no new messages. She pressed the main button just to hear his voice. "Hi, this is Fox Mulder. Leave a message after the beep." She played the recording a few more times, but he never said anything different. In the kitchen, she made a cup of tea, standing like a zombie with the broken counter edge at her back while the kettle whistled away. She drank it in his living room, sitting on what she considered her end of the couch. Every so often, she would look over at the other end and visualize him there, legs sprawled akimbo with his knees nearly hitting the coffee table. When she finished her tea, she set the empty mug on the table, using a back issue of "The Economist" as a coaster. She wandered idly over to his desk and flipped on the lamp. It gave no more clues to his whereabouts than it had the last time she'd looked. She sifted through bits and pieces of paper, pausing to smile at a doodle-head he had drawn of Skinner. She reached across and picked up one of the phone extensions, but then thought better of it and extricated her cell phone instead. "This is Agent Dana Scully," she said when a FBI tech answered on the other end. "I need anything you can get me on this number." She rattled off the digits Mulder had given her. "I need this as soon as possible." "Sure thing, Agent Scully," the woman replied. "Do we call you back at this number?" She recited Scully's cell. "Yes, that's fine." While she waited, Scully walked to Mulder's bedroom. She turned the light on in the hall and leaned against the doorjamb, her cheek pressed on the cool wood. She stroked the smooth edge next to her body as she studied the unmade bed. There was no smell of Diana here, just cotton sheets, night air, and the combination of male sweat, leather and sandalwood that she thought of as "Mulder." She slipped off her shoes and crawled into the bed, closing her eyes as her nose hit the pillow. She was so exhausted her head was spinning. Cradling the cell phone between her breasts, she curled in the spot where he slept and drifted off into dreams. When she woke, pale, fuzzy light filled the room. She lay there blinking in the gray dawn, an arm over her head. Then she heard the sound of a drawer closing in the living room. She sat straight up and listened harder. The floorboards groaned under someone's feet, and Scully slipped from the covers and tiptoed down the hall. Her heartbeat accelerated like a subway train as she braced herself for the sight of him. The word "Mulder" was already in her throat as she peered around the corner, but she choked it back immediately when she saw who was in the apartment. The man heard her and turned around. "Agent Scully," Detective Rivera said. He had a stack of Mulder's papers in his hands. "What are you doing here?" she asked, feeling less than equal as she stood there in her stocking feet and rumpled suit. "I have a warrant," he said. "What are you doing here?" "A warrant for what?" "For pretty much anything I want," he replied as he returned his attention to Mulder's desk. "My boss is getting rather cranky that I haven't been able to find Agent Mulder yet, so I have a wide latitude in where I can look." He yanked open a file drawer. "Yoo hoo, Mr. Mulder -- are you in there?" When no one answered, he shrugged and straightened up. "Guess I can cross that one off the list." "I don't know what you expect to find there," she said, crossing to join him. "I can assure you there's nothing here that says where he is." "As much as I'd like to rely on your assurances, Agent Scully, I can't very well take that back to the station, now can I?" He tossed aside an old newspaper. "You sleep here often?" he asked without looking at her. "Your warrant doesn't cover that information." He did look then, and smiled at her. "You're a quick one, eh? I like that. Let's try a different one then: did Agent Fowley sleep here often?" Scully knew he wanted a reaction, so she didn't give him one. "I can't speak to Agent Fowley's sleeping habits." "They were lovers, though, right?" He waited a beat but she didn't help him out. "At least they were a long time ago, that's what I'm hearing. Then there was some sort of trouble and she left town." He knelt down and tugged on another drawer. This one was locked. "I don't suppose you have a key for this," he said, looking up at her. She just folded her arms. "Right," he said with a sigh, and took out a lock pick. "This trouble Mulder got into with Fowley, did he tell you about it? He and she were playing hot prowl over at the NIH." "I don't know what you're talking about." "Of course not. No one could ever prove it, I guess, which is why they both still had careers." He grunted as he got the file drawer open. "And, from what I gather, they were working together again, even though Agent Fowley has taken over Mulder's old position on the X-files. That had to sting, huh? He works his tail off to get that department open, she jets off overseas and then comes back to take his job away? I might want to shoot her too." "You said she was shot in the head with her own gun. Maybe she committed suicide." "Believe it or not, we considered that. But the shot was fired at least five feet from the victim, and there were no traces of gunpowder on her hands. Plus, you know, the gun was missing. That was a big clue right there." "Someone could have taken the gun." "Someone," he mused. "Yes." He took out the first file, a blue folder that made Scully freeze at the sight. Oh, God, she thought. No. "Brandt lab," he said as he flipped it open. "Interesting. That was the location of the alleged break-in, wasn't it? Some papers were missing..." Scully wanted to rip the thing away from him but there was nothing she could do. "Oh, these aren't research files at all, are they?" he said, and he glanced up at her. "No, this is something else entirely. If I'm not mistaken, this is motive." "Then you're mistaken," Scully told him as her cell phone rang. She answered it, and it was the lab. "Agent Scully? We have an answer on the number you gave us. It's a German cell phone number and the phone is owned by the Bureau. It's been checked out for the last several years to Agent Diana Fowley. I dumped the incoming and outgoing numbers for the last thirty days. Did you want to see them?" Scully's stomach did a triple back flip. "Yes, uh, yes I would, but let me come get them, okay? I'll be there as soon as I can." She snapped the phone shut and turned back to Rivera, who looked her over. "Tell Mulder hi." "If I talk to him, I will." He waved the folder at her. "I'll be taking this with me." "Go ahead. That information is seven years old." "Maybe so," he said as he wafted the folder under his nose. "But the betrayal smells minty fresh." X-X-X-X-X- Mulder showed up late and smelling like Diana's perfume. She caught a good whiff of him as he hurried past to his seat, but she stopped him before he could sit down. "Don't bother," she said as she stood up. "Kersh wants to see us." "Maybe we've won the manure pile sweepstakes," he said without humor. She walked quickly, but still it took him no effort at all to fall into step beside her. "I have a feeling it's about Dr. Brandt," she said as they reached the elevator. "How would he even know? Brandt's not exactly on the FBI's radar screen." "I expect that will be his point when he reprimands us." For the first time, she really looked at him and noticed the shadows under his eyes. He'd missed a spot while shaving, too. "Late night?" she asked. "Not really," he answered shortly as the doors slid open. She trailed him inside, and he leaned against the metallic wall with his eyes closed. She wondered if he was hung-over. Kersh did not immediately look up when they arrived at his office, choosing instead to finish reading some document on his desk. He signed the bottom with a flourish. "Sit," he instructed, still not giving them his full attention. They each took a chair and waited, and at length, he looked up at them over the rims of his glasses. "Christopher Brandt," he said. "Who wants to explain it to me?" Scully looked at her lap, and Mulder cleared his throat. "Explain what?" "What you are doing investigating his death. I'm sure there must be a very good reason. In fact, I know there must be, because this was not an assignment that I handed down, so I'm quite positive that you have adequate justification for this insubordination." "Technically, if you didn't hand down the order, then it wasn't insubordination," replied Mulder. Scully interjected before Kersh could form an answer. "His widow asked specifically for our help, sir." "His widow. I see." He peaked his fingertips together for a moment and then scratched the underside of his chin. "This widow, is she a federal agent?" "No, sir." "And you two haven't formed a private detective company, have you?" Neither of them answered that one. "Because the last time I checked, civilians could not just call up and requisition help directly from the FBI." "We're public servants," Mulder said. "She's the public." Kersh leaned across the desk. "Let's get this straight right now. If you're anybody's servants, you're *my* servants, and you will do as you're told. The district police department has this matter well in hand, and I know you've got piles of work to do downstairs." "Piles, yes," Mulder agreed. "Big, fat smelly piles." Kersh glowered at him. "One more word and you're suspended two weeks without pay, and before you decide to test me on that, it will be four weeks for Agent Scully." Mulder kept his mouth shut, and Kersh sat back in his seat, rocking a bit as he contemplated them. "There will be no more long, unexcused absences," he said. "You get a half-hour for lunch and then you're back at your desks doing the work that I've given you. Am I making myself clear on this point?" "Yes, sir," Scully replied. Kersh waited expectantly for Mulder's answer. He finally managed a grudging, "Yes, sir." Back at the elevator, Scully hit the button with more force than was strictly necessary. "I see somehow Agent Fowley managed to miss out on this fun," she said. "I wonder why he didn't want to rap her knuckles too." "She doesn't report to him," Mulder answered as he rubbed his head with one hand. "Maybe. Maybe not." "What's that supposed to mean?" "Don't you think it's a little funny that yesterday she's volunteering to take this investigation away from us, and today that's exactly what happened? You were the one wondering how Brandt even got onto Kersh's radar screen." "And you think Diana told him?" he asked as they entered the empty elevator car. "What reason would she have to do that? I think it's far more likely that Brandt's secretary complained." "Maybe. I just find the timing fishy." "Diana didn't talk to him." "You're sure." "Yes, I'm sure." He hit the stop button and the car halted. "First of all, she only offered to take on more of the leg work, not to take over the entire investigation. Secondly, she made that offer because she knows how hard it is for me - - for us -- trying to get out from under Kersh's thumb. She's on our side, Scully." "Mulder, you obviously know her much better than I do, but things aren't the same as when she left before. She's in charge of the X-Files now, not you. You want them back and she wants to keep them. I'm not sure that puts you on the same side." "You don't know all the facts," he said, shaking his head. "A call to Kersh keeps both of us stuck in manure," she pointed out. "She didn't call him." "Fine," she said, dismissing him. She reached for the button. "Whatever you say." "She didn't call him, Scully," he said again, and the certainty in his voice made her stop. She looked back at him, her hand hovering near the button. He held her gaze and let her see the truth. Mulder knew very well that Diana hadn't called. He knew because he'd been with her. X-X-X-X X-X-X-X-X-X-X Chapter Five X-X-X-X-X-X-X Without an office, Scully took the results of Diana's cell phone dump to a rarely-used restroom on the eighth floor, where she isolated herself in a stall and read the papers. Neither Diana nor Mulder seemed to have used the phone much; there were only a dozen calls over the last month. Scully recognized the Gunmen's number at the bottom. Based on the dates, Mulder had made only one other call, to a number she did not recognize, but the area code was local. Diana had called Mulder twice on his cell, both times after Christopher Brandt's death, and the final call came a few hours before she'd died. It had lasted nearly five minutes, so she must have reached him. Scully leaned against the cold metal door and tried to imagine what they could have said, whether Diana had denied what was in the papers or whether lies and the truth had become so enmeshed that she could no longer distinguish between them. The other number that stood out for her was identified as Christopher Brandt's office at the NIH. Diana had called him two days before his death, and despite everything, Scully still didn't know why. She didn't like the way the odds played out. Brandt was on the call list, and he was dead. Now the owner of the phone was also dead. This left Mulder holding the phone. Right before the call to Brandt's office, Diana had talked to someone for nearly ten minutes. The lab had been unable to come up with a name to match that number. It was not a pay phone but an unregistered cell, owner unidentified. The restroom door swung open, and Scully jumped. As the other woman took the stall next to hers, she tucked the phone list away and hurried out of the room. She bypassed the elevator and took the stairs, exiting from the side of the building. Wind rustled the brittle leaves as she jogged down the street. She glanced over her shoulder but no one appeared to follow. Four blocks later, she found the payphone she wanted in front of a deli, where the smell of corned beef wafted out through the vents. She searched her pockets for change and dropped in a pair of quarters. She dialed the number Mulder had called and then held a hand over her ear to block out the traffic noise. The phone rang through and a moment later, someone came on the line. "Skinner." She slammed the phone down, but held tight to the receiver. Skinner said he hadn't talked to Mulder. He had been pumping her for information. She took out the list of calls again and tried the other unidentified number. Her fingers shook as she punched the buttons. This time, the call went through but the person on the other end said nothing. Scully listened to the static for a moment. "Who is this?" she asked. No one replied. "Who am I talking to?" The person waited another moment and then clicked off the line. She hunted around until she found another pair of quarters and dropped them in the slot. She hit redial, but this time no one answered her call. X-X-X-X-X There were many Sundays that Mulder would have loved to return home to find Scully waiting for him on his stoop; in fact, he'd dreamt similar scenarios over the years so many times that he did a quick double take at the sight of her sitting there. The setting sun turned her hair to copper, and she wore a pale blue blouse with the sleeves rolled up and sandals on her feet. She bore no traces of makeup and her glasses sat perched on her head. The total effect was to send him back in time to their first days together, when she was as green as a new leaf and just as tender. She'd looked expectant then, too, waiting for him to prove himself to her. These years later, Mulder thought perhaps she was still waiting. He walked over to her and leaned on the railing. "You were just in the neighborhood?" She picked up a file folder from the step next to her. "I did a little investigation into Agent Fowley's work in Berlin. This is a summary of her accomplishments over the past five years." She handed him the folder, and he flipped the cover to find it was empty. He turned it upside down and shook it. "There's nothing here." "Exactly. She went to Europe and disappeared." Mulder shut the folder and handed it back to her. When Scully didn't reach to take it, he dropped in her lap. "You know as well as I do that international intelligence work is highly classified. I'm not surprised that there isn't any record of her activities." "I called the office in Berlin. No one there had heard of her." "Did you also ask if they had Prince Albert in a can? Of course they're not going to answer your questions over the phone." "Why did she come back here, Mulder? Did she ever tell you that?" "She wanted to come home." Scully's chin dropped as she considered this. "Home," she repeated. "Right. Back to the states." "Back to the X-files?" He looked down the street to where someone was doing a terrible job of parallel parking. "That was Kersh's idea, not hers." Scully did not answer immediately. Instead, she took out folded sheets of paper from her back pocket, unfolded them, and smoothed them over her knees. "She arrived back in the United States on March third of last year. On March fourth, she accessed this file." He took the pages from her and scanned them. "This is my work history." "She started with you, but she didn't stop there. She looked up mine too." Scully stood up, and with the steps separating them, they were almost eye-to-eye. "Well?" she asked. "Aren't you going to say anything?" "I don't know what you want me to say. So she looked up our files. I guess she was curious. But you can hardly fault her for behavior that you yourself have engaged in." "I had reasons." Mulder's head was starting to hurt. Scully was determined to make Diana into the enemy, and in a way he couldn't blame her. It had been one hell of a year, and there was no other donkey around upon which to affix a tail. "You have no reason to trust her," he said softly. "I get that. What I'm asking you to see is that she's in the same position as you." "Last I looked she was in your position, Mulder. In your office with your desk and your files. What I don't understand is why I'm the only one asking questions about how she got there." He shook his head. "You are more alike than you know. I wish you could see that." "You want me to trust her." "I want you to trust me." Uncertainty clouded her eyes and she backed up until she hit the rail. The action made her wince in pain more than it should have, and he stepped forward. "Are you okay?" "I'm fine," she said quickly. "What happened to your back?" he said, trying to see around her. "Nothing. It's just a bruise." She moved to the left at the same time he did and they ended up practically on top of one another. He froze and so did she, inches apart, but she would not look at him. Her skin radiated warmth in the cooling night air. Gently, he traced one finger up her bare forearm until it hit her sleeve. She shivered. He tucked the finger under the fold and crooked it, causing her to tilt towards him just a bit more. She turned her head to the side. "Tell me," he said, his voice just above a whisper. "You haven't trusted her from the beginning and I want to know why." She shook her head, mute. He moved his finger from her sleeve to her face, turning her back to him with just a slight pressure on her chin. "Why?" he asked again. Her eyes were clear and bright, but her mouth had tightened into a thin line. "She walked away from you," she said at last, and the words stunned his chest. "She left to protect me," he said when he could talk again, and Scully looked at her feet once more. "I know," she said, "but I'm not sure that I ever could." He tugged her to him with one arm behind her neck, her head resting in the crook of his elbow. She hugged him back and pressed her nose against his breastbone. Her glasses slipped to the side but she didn't seem to care. Closing his eyes, he leaned down to breathe her in, her hair tickling at his nose. "Come upstairs with me." She went rigid at the words but didn't pull away, so he tightened his hold and repeated them, his lips hot on her scalp. "Come upstairs." "Mulder..." His name seemed dragged out of her against her will, and he felt her fingernails prick his back. She had avoided his apartment as much as possible since the summer, and he wasn't sure whether it was her collapse and near death that had her running scared or if she was just that concerned that he might try to kiss her again. He opened his palm against her ribcage and felt the hammer of her heartbeat. "Scully," he said, just in case she thought there was confusion. He rubbed the side of her breast with his thumb, stopping just short of the nipple. "Scully, come." She let out a choked noise and it was all he could do not to drag her through the door. Her breath tickled his skin through his shirt and her hands kneaded his back. She jerked back a little and he thought she was leaving, but instead she grabbed his hand from her breast and squeezed so hard it stopped his circulation. He got the door open in record time and pulled her to the elevator. Once inside, he watched the numbers tick by in slow motion and cursed himself for not living on the first floor. When the ding signaled their arrival and the heavy doors parted, they both stood there. The hallway loomed. "After you," he said with a sweep of his hand. Scully put her head down and walked quickly toward his door. She stood there, shifting from one foot to the other while he struggled with his keys. He practically gasped with relief when the door came open, stumbling inside with no grace whatsoever. Scully stepped primly over the threshold but moved no further than his small pile of shoes. "You, uh, you want something to drink?" It was hard to make conversation with an erection pressing insistently against his jeans. Wide-eyed, Scully shook her head. She had her lower lip caught between her teeth and he wanted to suck it back out. He clenched his fists to avoid reaching out and grabbing her. "Maybe...maybe I should just go," she said, and took a step back. "No," he blurted, and she froze. He licked his lips. Diana's ghost had bullied her up here, and if that's what it took to get her to stay... "You said... you said you wouldn't walk away," he told her softly. The raw emotion that flashed over her face told him he'd hit his mark. He stepped closer. "Don't go," he said, and held out his hand. After a moment, she took it, and either she was shaking or he was. He gripped her tightly and started leading her to the bedroom. It was twilight, drenched in purple shadows with a slight breeze wafting in from his open window. He sat on the rumpled sheets and pulled her between his legs. She smiled at him almost sadly and laid her palm against his cheek. Her fingertips toyed with the hair at his temple. He rested his hands on her hips, his thumbs through her belt loops, and urged her even closer. She shifted her hand to the back of his neck and gathered his face to her breasts. Between them, his fingers went to work on the buttons of her blouse. He had to sit back to finish the job, and she was breathing unsteadily by the time he parted the soft cotton. He circled her bellybutton with one finger and it quivered. Then he replaced his hand with his mouth, pressing lingering kisses to her stomach, her ribs, her collarbone and her chin. When he reached her mouth, she held his face in both hands, anchoring him by the ears as if he might try to get away. The first touch of her tongue sent tingles down the back of his neck. Her tongue was like the rest of her, small, strong and quick, and he opened wider to let her have her way. He was openly fondling her ass by now and her breasts kept brushing against his shoulders. She pushed him back onto the bed and climbed up so that her knees were on the mattress, straddling him. His hips bucked of their own accord and nearly bumped her off. The motion sent her glasses back down over her face, where they landed slightly crooked on the end of her nose. He reached up to remove them, but she took his hand. "I want to see you," she murmured, and so together they righted the glasses on her face. He repeated the caress several times, tucking her hair behind her ears, then letting his hands roam down her shoulders to the loose flaps of her blouse. He tugged it off. Her nipples stood out against the thin silk of her bra, and Mulder felt his mouth water at the sight. So intent was he on her breasts that he was shocked when they suddenly dis